logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Ha-Joon Chang

23 Things they don't tell you about Capitalism

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2010

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Thing 18Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Thing 18 Summary: “What Is Good for General Motors Is Not Necessarily Good for the United States”

Free-market economists typically argue that if something is good for business, it is also good for the broader economy and that governments should therefore give businesses maximum freedom and leeway instead of making it difficult for them to operate. Pointing to the history of companies such as General Motors (GM), which used its success as a manufacturer of military supplies during World War II as a stepping stone to postwar success, these economists suggest that any regulations on such companies would only stifle beneficial growth.

Chang counters that some regulations can actually help businesses. He returns to the story of GM, this time chronicling the company’s decline. As overseas competitors began to produce superior vehicles, GM appealed to the government for protection rather than refining its products, even as it turned its attention from manufacturing to finance. The company’s decline continued until, in 2009, the US government took over the company to keep it from failing, costing taxpayers nearly $60 billion. Clearly, GM’s shortsighted decisions were not in the national interest.

Pointing to countries in East Asia where rapid growth occurred in a heavily regulated environment, Chang identifies several ways in which regulations can help businesses. Some regulations, such as those protecting natural resources, can keep businesses from sacrificing long-term viability for short-term profit. In other cases, regulations can help businesses invest in areas like employee training, which may not pay off in the short term but raise collective productivity over time.

Thing 18 Analysis

In this essay, Chang takes a story-centered approach, focusing on the history of General Motors as a case study. Although Chang focuses on one company rather than providing additional examples, GM is an iconic company that aptly serves as a symbol of US industry as a whole. This essay underscores the theme of Deconstructing Free-Market Economics Dogma, as Chang uses the story of GM’s decline to indicate troubling trends and forces broadly at work in the economy. Conversely, a free-market economist could attribute some of the blame for GM’s downfall to the government for pandering to GM’s wishes by first implementing protectionist policies and then bailing the company out, moves that both violated free-market principles. At the very least, this essay illustrates the potential for perverse incentives to dilute the efficacy of the market. Even had another, more efficient company arisen in GM’s place, thousands of lives would have been impacted in the transition.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text