logo

50 pages 1 hour read

George Orwell

Coming Up for Air

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1939

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 4Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 4, Chapter 1 Summary

Bowling decides to approach Lower Binfield via Chamford Hill; although the route is less direct, he wants to see the town for the first time as he did when he was a boy returning from fishing. Driving through the countryside is a strange experience for Bowling: The roads seem wider than he remembered and there are fewer trees. On the outskirts of town, a new housing development and a massive cemetery have been built. Bowling recalls that there used to be an oak plantation where the new houses stand and that, in the summer, anemones used to bloom like a carpet under the trees.

When Bowling arrives at the top of Chamford Hill, he is stunned to discover that the small town he grew up in had been swallowed by a mid-sized manufacturing town. He estimates that the population has grown from about 2,000 to 25,000 since he last saw it. Bowling studies the city and is dismayed to find that none of the old landmarks he knew—such as the market square and the brewery—are visible. Getting lost as he drives through the unfamiliar city, Bowling asks a woman for directions to the marketplace, but she doesn’t recognize the landmark. The second person he asks for help calls it the Old Marketplace, and Bowling eventually finds his way back to the old town center. Although he initially upset, Bowling’s mood changes for the better when he checks in at the George, an upscale hotel that used to be the town pub. But then it changes to annoyance when the woman at the front desk fails to recognize his last name as he had expected she would, given his family history in the town.

Part 4, Chapter 2 Summary

Bowling has lunch in the dining room at the George, where he spots an attractive blonde woman, possibly a widow, and thinks about trying to sleep with her. He spends a few hours drinking in the hotel, then walks through town toward the site of his family home/workshop, which he discovers has been turned into a tea shop. He orders a tea, studying the changes, and sees the ghost of the home as it used to be when he was a boy. For some reason, Bowling feels guilty spending time in the teashop, and when the shy waitress won’t respond to his attempts at conversation, he leaves.

Disappointed, Bowling walks toward the church to visit his parents’ graves. He isn’t sure what he should feel and ultimately decides he feels nothing. Inside, the church looks and smells exactly as Bowling remembers it, and he once again remembers the bible story about Og, the king of Bashan, which had inspired the whole trip back on that January day. A vicar approaches to give him a tour, and Bowling realizes that he is the same vicar who was serving when he was a boy and that Bowling himself is the same age that the vicar was when Bowling was a boy. He wonders if young men now think about him as an old monster. He is relieved that the vicar doesn’t recognize him.

Bowling returns to the George and feels suddenly desperate to sleep with the blonde widow. As soon as he tries to speak to her, she glares at him, prompting Bowling to retreat to the hotel’s private bar, which is attached to both the public bar and a bottle shop. He tries to ask the bartender about the changes he’s seen in Lower Binfield, but the conversation turns quickly to the war. He is amused, but not surprised, to learn that Binfield House has been transformed into a mental health institution holding 60 patients.

Part 4, Chapter 3 Summary

Bowling wakes up the next morning feeling hungover and miserable. Opening the window, he is annoyed to find that the street is already bustling with businessmen and young students. He soon regrets these thoughts, and feels like a miserable old man. He thinks gloomily that maybe he is a ghost. Compared with him, the people below are alive. After breakfast, Bowling feels better, and decides that if he is a ghost, he should act like one and visit his old haunts. As he leaves the hotel, Bowling is surprised to see a military-style parade of young children marching with one of his old teachers and holding a sign reading “Britons Prepare.” He speculates that this parade is a kind of propaganda designed to diminish resistance to the idea of war.

Bowling spends two days exploring the town, imagining the way things used to be and projecting a map of his childhood onto the present. He notes that several farms and ponds have been paved over and that many of the shops in the center of town have changed ownership, except for Sarazins’, the company that ruined his father’s business. On Sunday, Bowling decides to go fishing; as he approaches the river, he is shocked to find teahouses and tourist and ice cream shops lining the riverbanks. The river itself is crowded with young people on boats with gramophones. Bowling walks along the river, noting the changes in color and quality of the river and wonders if there are even fish left in it. Leaving the river, Bowling impulsively puts a penny in an arcade game that guesses weight. Bowling learns that he’s gained four pounds and assumes that it’s the result of all his drinking.

Part 4, Chapter 4 Summary

Bowling drives back to the George, but finds that the bar is closed. He decides to go for a walk, and notices a woman in her 40s whom he feels compelled to follow. He describes the woman as tall, fattish, and dressed in a shabby manner. When the woman stops to talk in a shop doorway, Bowling gets a full view of her face and realizes that it’s his first serious girlfriend, Elsie Wells. He is shocked to discover how the years have changed Elsie. He remembers the soft, beautiful woman she was in her youth, and wonders how she turned into the overweight hag he now believes her to be.

Bowling and Elsie make eye contact, but she makes no sign that she recognizes him. Fascinated by this relic of his past, Bowling follows Elsie through the streets of Lower Binfield to a cramped, dirty tobacco and candy shop that he assumes belongs to Elsie and her husband. He enters the shop under the pretense of buying a pipe and is dismayed when Elsie still does not recognize him. Bowling asks for an amber-tipped pipe and watches critically as she searches for it. Eventually Elsie calls in her husband, who is named George, to help find an appropriate pipe. Bowling wonders how many other men named George Elsie has slept with and leaves without buying a pipe. He returns to the George and has dinner, then goes to a crowded pub and gets drunk with some travelling salesmen. He wakes up the next morning with a horrible headache.

Part 4, Chapter 5 Summary

Bowling considers the source of his headache: for three days, he’s been drinking from the moment the bar opens to closing time. He reflects that there isn’t much else to do in Lower Binfield besides drink. Once again, he looks out the window and resents the people on the street below, whom he considers to be his enemies. He spends the morning thinking darkly about the ugliness of present-day Lower Binfield and wondering whether the secret pool at Binfield House has also changed for the worse. He imagines the possibility that, after all these years, no one else has found the pool.

In the late afternoon, Bowling sets out for Binfield House. He is relieved to see that the thick forest of beech trees lining the road still exists and begins to grow excited. He briefly considers lying about a mentally ill wife in order to gain access to the institution at Binfield House, then realizes that he might not need to enter the grounds in order to reach the pool. When he finally reaches the large pond, where he caught his first fish with Joe and the Black Hand, he sees that a new housing development has grown around it. When Bowling asks a resident about the changes, he learns that the development was built as an all-natural alternative to the expanding town below. The resident sheepishly admits that the secret pool Bowling has been dreaming about was drained and is now a garbage dump. Bowling leaves, filled with resentment at these new residents and lamenting the changes in the British countryside.

When he returns to the hotel, Bowling hears an SOS announcement on the emergency radio calling for him to return home to his sick wife, Hilda. Bowling ignores the message, assuming it’s a trick of Hilda’s. He thinks about the times in the past when Hilda has caught him being unfaithful and wonders how she managed to trick the SOS radio controllers.

Part 4, Chapter 6 Summary

After breakfast the next morning, Bowling walks through town smoking a cigar. Suddenly, he hears the sound of planes overhead and the whistle of a bomb. Without consciously thinking about it, Bowling throws himself onto the ground. For a moment, he thinks that the war has begun, and the Germans are bombing Lower Binfield. Bowling waits for a second bomb, but nothing happens. When he stands, he sees a herd of pigs running down the street; after a moment, he realizes that it’s actually a parade of children in gas masks running for safety.

Eventually, Bowling and the people of Lower Binfield learn that the bomb was not dropped by the Germans, but by a Royal Air Force plane running a failed training exercise. He follows a crowd towards the site of the bomb, just 50 yards from where his uncle’s workshop used to be. He sees that a grocery shop has been completely obliterated and that the home next door has been blown open, so that it looks like a dollhouse. Inside, he sees a single leg that has been blown off a body, with blood mixing with a broken jar of marmalade. Bowling learns that three people died in the explosion.

That afternoon, Bowling checks out of the George, with only three pounds left in from his secret horde. He leaves Lower Binfield confident that the town he knew as a boy no longer exists and that he’ll never fish again. He considers the bomb as a sign from the Royal Air Force that his old life is gone. On the way home, as he drives past London, Bowling imagines the lives of the millions of people who call the city home. He thinks once again about the ways in which the war will change their lives. He speculates that no one will be able to escape the violence of the war or the misery that will come after the war.

Part 4, Chapter 7 Summary

As he approaches the suburbs, Bowling begins to think that Hilda may really be sick. He speculates that his change of heart has to do with a change of scenery: As he enters his neighborhood, he feels more pessimistic than ever, as well as guilty about his trip. He reflects that the future is irrelevant to people like him and Hilda and thinks that the present is the only time that matters. He feels sick at the thought of Hilda lying dead in their home. Bowling acknowledges that the reader might be surprised by his worry for Hilda; He compares her to his own face, explaining that he can’t imagine his life without her.

When Bowling enters the house, Hilda is gone; however, his children quickly assure him that she hasn’t been sick and that she is out with Mrs. Wheeler. Bowling feels relieved until he sees her coming up the path, and realizes that she is not happy to see him. He confronts Hilda about the SOS message on the radio, which he now feels confident was part of her plan to catch him cheating. Hilda claims not to have sent the SOS message and confronts Bowling about his lie about Birmingham. Hilda reveals that she wrote the hotel Bowling claimed to be staying at and received a response saying the hotel had been closed for years. The same day, she received the letter Bowling had asked a friend to post from Birmingham, which confirmed to her that he was lying about where he was.

Despite Bowling’s attempts to explain himself, Hilda is convinced that he has spent the week with another woman. Bowling thinks that Hilda would never understand why he needed to spend the week in Lower Binfield and that her world stops at the edge of their housing estate. As the argument continues, Bowling’s anxieties about the war fade into the background, and as the novel closes, Bowling considers that he has three options: to try to make Hilda understand, to lie and say that he doesn’t remember where he’s been, or to let her believe that he’d been with a woman and take his punishment. The novel ends without explicitly disclosing which option Bowling chooses.

Part 4 Analysis

Central to Bowling’s criticism of the new Lower Binfield is the lack of wildlife and natural beauty as a result of modernization. As he drives up Chamford Hill, Bowling recalls that “in the old days there used to be huge beeches growing in the hedgerows, and in places their boughs met across the road and made a kind of arch” (110). On the outskirts of town, he recalls that “there used to be a little oak plantation, and the trees grew too close together, so that they were very tall and thin, and in spring they ground underneath them used to be smothered in anemones” (110). These descriptions of trees forming arches across the road and carpets of flowers evoke a town enveloped by greenery. This natural abundance of the past contrasts starkly with the town in its present state, where “there weren’t any fields or any bulls or any mushrooms” (112). Instead, Bowling describes “houses, houses everywhere, little raw houses with their grubby window curtains and their scraps of back-garden that hadn’t anything in them except a patch of rank grass or a few larkspurs straggling among the weeds” (112). This image of private yards failing to thrive offers a dark contrast to the lush, diverse natural world of Bowling’s memory. In Bowling’s eyes, the contrast is evidence that the town has degraded with time and points to the theme of Disillusionment and Nostalgia.

The isolation Bowling feels as he wanders in London in Part 1 of the novel becomes more intense in Part 4. As he explores Lower Binfield, he is keenly aware of the distance between him and the town’s new inhabitants. Although he calls them “bloody interlopers, twenty thousand gate-crashers who didn’t even know my name” (124), he also acknowledges that he is the outsider and worries that “I’m dead, and they’re alive” (124). Throughout his first few days in the town, Bowling spends his days largely isolated from the people living and working in Lower Binfield: “I was a ghost, and if I wasn’t actually invisible, I felt like it” (125). When he finally sees someone who can affirm his place in the town, his old girlfriend Elsie, she seems like an entirely different person, and doesn’t recognize him. Even when their fingers touch, Bowling notes that there was “no kick, no reaction. The body doesn’t remember” (132). Bowling is openly resentful of Elsie’s failure to recognize him. He seems not to be able to understand that he is as much changed—for the worse—and unrecognizable from her perspective as she is from his.

Bowling’s attempts to reconnect to his boyhood come to a climax when he discovers that his secret pool at Binfield House has been drained and converted to a garbage dump. Throughout the novel, the secret pool filled with giant fish is a powerful symbol of Bowling’s unfulfilled desires: to spend time in nature, to feel like he’s in control of something, to return to his youth. While the empty pool—“a great round hole, like an enormous well, twenty or thirty feet deep” (137)—reflects the emptiness Bowling perceives in himself, for Bowling, the act of replacing wild, untamed nature with man-man garbage is a perfect encapsulation of what is wrong with the modern world.

Bowling’s anxieties about the war come to a head when a bomb is accidentally dropped on Lower Binfield. The bomb’s explosion acts as a violent interruption of the fantasy of the past Bowling is seeking in Lower Binfield, rounding out the theme of War and Memory. He describes the sound of the bomb falling “like the Day of Judgement” (140) and the feeling of “being suddenly shoved up against reality” (141). For Bowling, the reality of the situation is that “the old life’s finished, and to go about looking for it is just a waste of time. There’s no way back to Lower Binfield” (143). The climactic explosion of the bomb in this final section of the poem is evidence that the upcoming war is an inevitable, inescapable fact.

In the final chapter of the novel, Bowling returns home, to Hilda and to a present in which domestic strife crowds out the impending strife of war. Confronted with Hilda’s suspicions, he has an about-face: “No use playing injured innocence any longer. All I wanted was the line of least resistance” (151), which presumably is to allow Hilda to believe that she has caught him, much as he has been preoccupied with catching fish. The final line of the novel—“Damn it! I knew which it would have to be!” (151)—suggests his surrender to the exigencies of the present.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text