47 pages • 1 hour read
Octavia E. ButlerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: The Chapter 29 Summary contains racist language and graphic violence.
Shori tells Preston what she has learned about Theodora’s murder and demands Katharine’s death. Preston warns her that killing Katharine could put Shori’s symbionts at risk. He explains that Theodora was most likely murdered to make Shori seem mad with grief during the trial and destroy her credibility. He advises her to formally challenge Katharine during the next meeting so the Council will question and judge her actions. Still, Shori is determined to have her revenge even if Katharine isn’t found guilty. Because challenging Katharine will result in her expulsion as the Silk advocate, Shori must give up Vladimir as her advocate to keep the trial numerically fair. Preston advises Shori to ask Joan to be her new advocate because she is a Council member. Shori finds Joan expecting her. Joan prepares her with tough questions and explains that she must not lose her temper. She also explains that Shori’s attachment to the deceased Theodora is normal.
On the second night of the Council, Katharine denies Shori’s accusation and claims to not know where Jack Roan is. Like the Silks, Katharine accuses Shori of not being Ina because of her biological immaturity and human DNA. Although some members stand by Katharine, the majority of the Council ultimately votes to remove her because she is racist. The proceedings continue with the Silks questioning the Gordon family. The Silks call upon their own doctor to attempt to present evidence of Shori’s mental incapacity. The doctor finds her memory loss curious, but in the end, reaches no damning conclusions. When it is Shori’s turn to call upon someone, she questions one of the younger, unmated Russell sons because she assumes he will be more inexperienced with lying. When she asks him whether or not it is wrong to use humans as tools for murder, he vehemently says that it is wrong, but even she can tell he is lying. She is certain that the Council will sense the Silks’ guilt.
After the meeting, Shori goes for a run to clear her mind and returns to Theodora’s empty room in the guesthouse. She remembers how Theodora, shortly after arriving at the Gordons’, found her reading Ina history books and was fascinated by them. Later, Joel carries Shori to his room, and she asks him why he wants to be part of her family. He tells her that he likes who she is and how she makes him feel. She feeds from him roughly and immediately feels guilty about it, but he assures her that he is fine. Shori physically and verbally claims Joel as her own.
The next afternoon, Shori and her symbionts take a short road trip to distract themselves before the third and final Council meeting. As they picnic along the coast, they wonder about the Silks’ relationships with their symbionts. Shori asks her symbionts if they would be comfortable living with the Braithwaites for a short time while she acclimates to Ina life and comes of age. She also shares her plan to add more symbionts to their family and eventually join forces with another lone adult female.
Before the evening’s meeting, Shori approaches Margaret Braithwaite to ask about living with her family for a while. Margaret claims Shori may not want to live with them if the Council rules in the Silks’ favor. Shori still wants the Silks and Katharine to die for their crimes. Margaret tells her to be patient and to find her after the Council ruling.
During the final meeting, Russell makes a speech that appeals to his long-standing ties to the other Ina families and is meant to make Shori feel like an outsider. Shori chooses to question Preston. Because she is unfamiliar with Ina law, she asks if there is a process for Ina to make formal complaints about others’ harmful-but-nonlethal behavior; Preston tells her that this would call for a Council of the Goddess. The purpose of this line of questioning is to remind the judges that the Silks had less severe options for objecting to the genetic experiments of Shori’s family.
Preston goes from judge to judge, asking for their ruling. Some of them side with the Silks, citing Shori’s amnesia and the Silks’ upstanding reputation as reasons for their judgement. However, the majority side with Shori and find the Silks guilty of racism and murder.
The Silks are sentenced to disbandment. Their unmated sons will lose the Silk name and be adopted by different families all over the world; the remaining adult Silks will also lose their family name and be forced to keep the peace with the Matthews and Gordons for a minimum of 300 years. Each member of the Silk family must verbally accept their sentence or be sentenced to death. Russell Silk angrily refuses, launching himself at Shori and calling her several slurs, suggesting she will be the downfall of the Ina species. He is stopped by his brothers and sons, while the Gordons stand with Shori, ready to defend her. Russell then asks if Shori will join another family, and she realizes he is looking for a loophole: If Shori is no longer a Matthews, he can kill her without defying the sentence. Eventually, Russell, Milo, and the other Silks grudgingly accept their sentence, and the younger Silks are taken away from them.
Katharine is sentenced to amputation of both legs. She rejects the sentence because she claims murdering Theodora was a “minor crime” (303). Shori is outraged. Even when threatened with execution, Katharine refuses to accept her sentence, which prompts Preston to call for a break so she can rethink her decision. During the break, as Shori and her symbionts talk outside, Katharine charges toward Shori with a rifle. As Shori rushes to protect her symbionts, Katharine fires and hits her; Shori tackles her. They struggle on the ground until Shori tears out Katharine’s throat and breaks her neck before passing out.
When Shori wakes in her bed, she smells “meat” and blindly grabs for it—before realizing it is a yelling Wright. She stops herself from attacking him, and he offers her beef to help her recover. Shori scolds Wright for risking his life by being near her while she is injured, but he says he trusted her not to hurt him. He explains that the Gordon sons beheaded Katharine and burned her body, because the host family is responsible for executions. Katharine’s sister accepted the judgment on her family’s behalf, so Shori is safe from future attacks. Wright says the Braithwaites have invited Shori and her family to stay with them for a few years. Shori realizes that with her Biological Family (and Theodora) avenged and her symbionts safe, she can move on with her new family.
In the final chapters of the novel, emotions play a significant role in Shori’s fate. She is struggling with grief, learning patience, and satiating her hunger for blood while confronting her hunger for vengeance. She is angry at the Silks’ and Katharine’s disregard for her and her symbionts’ lives. To get justice for her family, Shori must conquer human emotions heightened by her Ina nature. The Silks are experts at manipulating emotions to obtain their goals, and expect her to succumb to the pressure. On the final day of the trial, Russell Silk’s rhetoric employs pathos and his family’s reputation to convince the Council that Shori is not one of their kind: “We Ina are vastly outnumbered by the human beings of this world [...] We could not live without them. But we are not them! We are not them! Children of the great Goddess, we are not them!” (291-92). His yelling, calculated pauses, and repetition all work together to attempt to persuade his audience. His rhetoric is also reminiscent of racist appeals for segregation and anti-miscegenation laws. Historically, these appeals were meant to instill fear of Black people and their “inferiority” to white people. Russell tries to frame Shori and other human-Ina hybrids as beneath pure Ina, his family and Katharine’s emotional manipulation framing the novel as an allegory for The Pervasiveness of Racism and White Supremacy.
Shori’s shift in Morality is also apparent. By the end of the novel, Shori believes Katharine’s death would mean justice for Theodora—whereas before, she could not imagine wishing someone dead. She herself acknowledges this shift: “I wanted to see the Silks dead, but I didn’t need to see them dead in the way that I needed to see Katharine dead. That wasn’t the way I should have felt, but it was the way I did feel” (289). She knows that on an ethical level, killing someone is wrong, but her duty to her new family has overtaken her previous sense of morality. However, this does not mean Shori has morally devolved. Instead, it shows her character development. She has emotionally evolved to value family like Ina are meant to. She is sacrificing her moral superiority to ensure her symbionts will be safe from future attacks. Interestingly enough, Shori’s words for the Council members who side against her could apply to herself as well: “Maybe they needed to see me [as mentally unstable]. Maybe it helped them deal with their conscience” (296). She needs to see herself as protecting her family and fulfilling her Ina duty in order to deal with her own conscience.
The story comes full circle at the end. In Chapter 1, Shori wakes up disoriented and starving in a cave, in which she mistakenly kills a human. The Epilogue mirrors this moment, but instead of killing and eating the “meat” she smells as she did before, she is able to stop herself from hurting Wright. This proves her emotional and mental development. Shori is now fit to care for her symbiont family because she trusts herself to keep them safe, even from herself. It also shows that Wright is able to think for himself, whereas throughout the novel, he has struggled with the concept of his free will. In Chapter 6, Shori orders Wright to keep his distance for his own protection, but he ultimately defies her and stays with her out of trust. Overall, this scene shows the promising “Found” Family dynamic that Shori and her symbionts will carry into the future.
By Octavia E. Butler
African American Literature
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Fantasy
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Horror, Thrillers, & Suspense
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
Science Fiction & Dystopian Fiction
View Collection