59 pages • 1 hour read
Thomas KingA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Cycles and repetition appear frequently in the novel to show that identity, the world, and storytelling are all in a constant process of creation and recreation. The cyclical structure is most evident in the creation stories plotline, with each one following the same structure and plot beats; however, even the realist plotline defies linearity by interspersing flashbacks that inform and recontextualize what is happening in the present. Thus, the motif of cycles and repetition works to frame the stories in such a way that there is no clear beginning, middle, or end. It is a mode of storytelling that sees stories as living, changing objects, rather than closed, finished products.
This reflects one of the main contrasts between oral and written storytelling: Once a story is written, it remains the same forever, which creates a paradigm in which a single narrative becomes the dominant one that everyone must know and accept. Oral stories are not indelible or authoritative in this way; instead, they are reinterpreted and retold, making the listener as important as the storyteller, as they could become the teller in the future.
Water appears in almost every aspect of the text: Each section starts with nothing but water; there is rain, puddles, and floods; and the novel’s title is a reference to the Canadian government’s promise that Indigenous people will retain rights to their land as long as the grass is green and the water runs. King even draws attention to the motif of water and floating in one of the fourth-wall breaking moments in the text when Coyote says, “All this floating [and water] imagery must mean something” (356).
On the most superficial level, water is the source of life. The flowing water and the floating imagery also mirror the sense openness, flexibility, and potential that King tries to evoke by emulating oral storytelling. Like the escaped elders floating from story to story, the reader floats from plotline to plotline, never stuck or bound to just one, with each one flowing together, then apart again—that is, except where that flowing is stopped by the colonial intervention of dam, threatening both life and Indigenous cultural tradition.
Water also symbolizes cleansing and new beginnings. After making plans to turn his life around, Lionel is soaked when he is caught in the rain. The plans he made to go back to school are washed away, leaving him ready to be put on the right path by Eli and the elders. The rushing waters caused by the earthquake are enough to burst the dam, and while this water destroys the cabin as well, it opens the possibility of new beginnings as Norma attempts to rebuild it. Most fundamentally, however, water serves as the connective tissue between the different plotlines and serves as a reminder of the interconnectedness of all life—a belief that is central to Indigenous ways of thinking about the world.
Bill Bursum’s wall-sized TV display that is arranged to look like a map of North America is a symbol of the connection between mass media and colonial domination. The form and function of “The Map” embodies the monologic nature of mass media. It is a map of all North America, yet the televisions it is comprised of all show the same thing at once, suggesting that a single perspective, voice, or story in this form can easily become the dominant narrative.
The wide-reaching impact of mass media can be seen throughout the text: Almost all of the characters end up watching the same Western when it is on TV; Karen and George both comment that the Sun Dance is like something out of a movie; and Charlie’s father cannot get movie roles because he does not conform to the stereotype created by Hollywood. Bursum understands this, and it is partly why he is so proud of the display. He also seems to understand the insidious effect of mass media and its direct connection to power and control: “It was like having the universe there on the wall, being able to see everything, being in control” (129).
King even describes Bursum as “taking in the panorama” when watching his favorite Western on his display of screens (194), implying the power of the mass media is akin to the panopticon—an architectural prison design in which every cell is visible by a single guard. While the guard could not possibly observe every prisoner at once, theorist Michel Foucault explored the ways that the inmates are forced to self-regulate because they can never know whether they are being observed. This is precisely what happens with Lionel. He internalizes the white gaze and harmful stereotypes on display in Western films, and it emotionally paralyzes him. Thus, Lionel renders himself powerless through the media he consumes.
The cabin works as a symbol of Indigenous culture, history, and tradition. It is important that Eli’s mother built the cabin by herself, using the natural resources around her in a sustainable way. The cabin is modest but does the job it is supposed to do: provide the comfort and shelter of home. This runs counter to capitalistic excess of the dam, which not only changes the landscape and destroys the surrounding ecosystem, but also creates a lake with plots of land that are intended to be sold to generate profit.
For Eli, it is not until he returns home and realizes the threat the dam poses to the cabin that he is able to reconnect with his cultural roots. While he cannot pinpoint a specific moment that he made the decision to stay, he implicitly understands the importance of resisting the abuses of colonial expansion. Lionel also eventually recognizes the cultural, historical, and traditional importance of the cabin, as he suggests that he would like to move into it at the end of the novel.
It is also significant that when the cabin is destroyed in the flood, the family comes together to rebuild it using as many of the original materials as possible. This underscores the responsible and sustainable use of natural resources while retaining the family history and ensuring the past is not completely overwritten. Moreover, this places the cabin in line with the novel’s wider cyclical structure and motifs, suggesting that while the core of what made the cabin special remains, it can also be remade to better suit the next generation who will occupy it.
By Thomas King