42 pages • 1 hour read
Edward O. WilsonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In Chapter 10, Wilson turns his focus to true conservation science, which is not anti-humanity, as some new conservationists suggest. In fact, many leading conservation organizations, such as the World Wildlife Fund, Conservation International, and the Nature Conservancy, have developed policies that “bring humanity to center stage” (84), including efforts to provide healthcare and economic support to people living in and near nature reserves.
A critical part of conservation science is understanding ecosystems. Wilson describes the case of Great Smoky Mountains National Park, which is one of the best-studied nature reserves in the United States. The number of species within the park is between 60,000 and 80,000. The park consists of “specialized organisms braided and woven together” (88), like any other ecosystem. Extinctions cause ripples throughout the entire ecosystem, potentially leading to its collapse. According to Wilson, the study of ecosystems is in its infancy, yet this field is critical to saving the planet’s biodiversity. Wilson closes the chapter by emphasizing that the only way to “give the rest of Earth’s life a chance” is to study and discuss its ecosystems and avoid “quick fixes” that will likely do more harm than good to biodiversity (89).
Wilson describes scientific naturalists, of which he is one. In contrast to other scientists, they do not go into science to make a living. They are some of the hardest working, most underpaid, and least competitive of all scientists. There is also a general sense of comradery among them, which Wilson attributes to the “virtually unlimited number of discoveries that await” in the natural world (96). Scientific naturalists are interested in finding missing evolutionary links as well as rediscovering species presumed to be extinct.
Wilson utilizes one of his “favorite fantasies” to illustrate “the passion of the naturalist” (99). In his fantasy, he is paddling down a channel of the Choctawhatchee River, which flows through southeast Alabama and the Florida Panhandle and empties into the Gulf of Mexico. He hears and then sees two large ivory-billed woodpeckers. The last sighting of these woodpeckers was in the mid-20th century. According to Wilson, they were “one of the most spectacular birds of America” (99). The clear-cutting of trees drove them to extinction. They were so large that people who saw them would exclaim “Lord God, what is that” (99), and thus they were referred to as “the Lord God bird” (99). For Wilson, all naturalists want their “Lord God moment” (99), in which they discover or rediscover a species, adding to humanity’s rich experience of the natural world.
Wilson continues to explore conservation science, focusing on taxonomy and natural history, both of which are critical to the field. He reemphasizes the current weaknesses in ecosystems studies, including the fact that most species remain unknown and the lack of understanding of species interaction within an ecosystem. For Wilson, the field cannot advance “without a solid knowledge of the species composing one ecosystem at a time” (104). Taxonomy is central to this advancement, since it is the branch of science that focuses on classification of organisms, including their “anatomy, DNA, behavior, habitat, and other biological traits” (104).
Natural history refers to the scientific study of species primarily through observation. To Wilson, “the history of each species can be considered an epic” (106). By observing a species, scientists learn about the niche they occupy and their relationship to other species. Species do not live in isolation from one another. As a result, when humans allow one extinction, “we erase the web of relationships it maintained in life” (106). Since we do not fully understand how species interact in an ecosystem, Wilson emphasizes that we do not truly understand what impact extinction has on other species and the ecosystem. Mathematical models attempt to understand these interactions, but, as Wilson notes, the natural world is too complex.
Wilson provides several examples of peculiar species interactions, such as “giant killers.” Giant killers refer to a species of ant in South America that uses ambush teams to kill insects that are over 13,000 times the weight of an individual ant. These examples further illustrate the complexities of species interactions within an ecosystem.
Wilson begins to introduce the key players in the conservation movement, two of which he discusses in these opening chapters of Part 2. Naturalists, like Wilson himself, are the first group. These individuals have boots on the ground and are working to identify new species, learn everything they can about their evolutionary tree, and better understand how they interact with other species within their ecosystems. To Wilson, naturalists are the most passionate of scientists. The second group consists of conservation organizations, such as the Nature Conservancy (TNC), World Wildlife Fund, and Conservation International. Wilson has personal experience with many of these groups, having served on their advisory and governing boards throughout his career. These groups’ primary goal is to help conserve nature and reduce the threat of extinctions on the planet.
New conservationists often accuse traditional conservation groups of being anti-human, meaning that they “give scant attention to the welfare of people” living in and around nature preserves (83). Wilson disagrees and provides several examples of these groups working to promote economic development alongside conservation efforts. This is not to say that Wilson is not critical of conservation organizations. Later in Part 2, he criticizes TNC for its recent focus on “what nature can do for people,” noting that “the economy has moved to center stage, while biodiversity has faded” (134).
One of Wilson’s main intentions in his text is to demonstrate the interconnectedness of life. Specifically, each ecosystem “is a web of specialized organisms braided and woven together” (88). To Wilson, we must understand the identity and biology of species within an ecosystem, as well as how they interact with other organisms. If we lack an understanding of these two fundamental biological aspects, then “how can we understand the deep principles of sustainability” (103). In Chapter 12, Wilson provides several peculiar invertebrate interactions in nature, primarily to demonstrate the uniqueness and richness found within. For example, some species of ants raid the colonies of others, drive off the adults, kidnap the young in pupal stage, and force them to be part of their worker force as adults. These ant species are “slave makers.”
As part of this web of life, Wilson emphasizes that extinguishing one species leads to a chain reaction. Because of this interconnectedness, “we break many threads” (106). Wilson’s frustration over this reality is clear in these chapters. Because we do not know the true extent of biodiversity, we do not fully realize how many strands we are obliterating within an ecosystem.
By Edward O. Wilson