93 pages • 3 hours read
Esther ForbesA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
As Johnny tries to make himself look presentable for his meeting with Mr. Lyte, he daydreams about the new life of luxury he imagines before him. He plans to reward Mr. Lapham and Cilla for their kindness and leave the rest of their family empty-handed. At first, Mr. Lyte dismisses Johnny’s claim of kinship as “a very old story—a very old trick” (78), and the conversation between the merchant and the boy quickly devolves into an exchange of insults. However, the mention of the silver cup works a change. Mr. Lyte tells Johnny to bring the cup to his house that night.
When Johnny stops by the Laphams’ house to retrieve his cup, Mrs. Lapham orders him to stop insulting Mr. Tweedie and to give up any thought of marrying Cilla. Johnny retorts that he doesn’t like Cilla and tells Mrs. Lapham that he’ll soon be moving out anyway. To pass the time before his second meeting with Mr. Lyte, Johnny tells Rab all about his conversation with the merchant. Rab warns Johnny that Mr. Lyte is a greedy, unscrupulous man who tries to play both sides and profit off the Whigs and Tories alike. The Whigs oppose British rule while the Tories favor it, and Rab is a staunch Whig. Without Johnny having to ask, Rab gives him a clean shirt, a vest with silver buttons, and some cheese and bread. Rab wishes his friend luck and invites him to sleep at the printing office if the merchant does not give the boy the reception he hopes for.
At Mr. Lyte’s house, the merchant and a dozen of his relatives discuss the boy as though he is not there. Mr. Lyte asks the party to move to the dining room, but the young Lavinia remains behind. In the dining room, Mr. Lyte confirms that Johnny’s cup matches the rest of the family’s set and orders a sheriff to arrest Johnny for stealing the cup in August. The sheriff takes Johnny to jail. Johnny asks the sheriff to inform Rab of his arrest but not the Laphams.
The next morning, Johnny worries that the accusation of stealing the silver cup may send him to the gallows, but, overall, he feels calm in the certainty that his fortunes can only improve from his current predicament. Rab brings him food, books, and blankets. Rab wears the symbol of the Sons of Liberty, a mighty, semi-secret society that drives British officials out of Boston, damages Tories’ property, and can “at will paralyze trade, courts, government” (88).
The Laphams decry the Sons of Liberty as perpetrators of mob violence, but Johnny finds himself intrigued by the organization now that he knows his friend is a member. The jailer is also a Son of Liberty, so he moves Johnny to a nicer, private cell. Johnny’s case is set to be heard by Mr. Justice Dana on Tuesday. His best hope of avoiding the noose is if Cilla testifies that Johnny showed her the cup back in July. However, Mr. Lyte bribes the Laphams by placing a large order at the silversmith shop. Mr. Tweedie, still bitter over Johnny’s insults, also pressures the Laphams to keep Cilla out of court. Rab assures Johnny that he can get Cilla to the trial, and he recruits Josiah Quincy, the finest young lawyer in the city, to defend his friend.
During the trial, Mr. Lyte claims that Johnny stole the cup and asks that the boy be given the death penalty. Johnny’s testimony about his late mother, his accident, and his arrest moves his listeners. As Rab promised, Cilla testifies on his behalf. Even though Johnny never showed Isannah the cup, she flings herself on the judge and fervently argues for his innocence. Largely swayed by the Lapham girls, the judge dismisses the case against Johnny and returns the cup to him. Lavinia Lyte, who attended the trial, tells Isannah that she is beautiful before driving off in a carriage. Isannah kisses Johnny’s right hand, and he feels as though he might cry.
Mr. Quincy invites Johnny, Rab, Cilla, and Isannah to a restaurant so they can celebrate their victory. The establishment is frequented by Whigs, who congratulate Quincy on his triumph over the two-faced Mr. Lyte. The lawyer warns Johnny that he has made a powerful enemy in the merchant. Rab explains that he was able to spirit Cilla away to the courthouse by showing Mrs. Lapham, who cannot read, a letter from Governor Hutchinson on an unrelated matter.
The autumn grows cold, and Johnny finds a sea captain who will hire him on as a cabin boy for a voyage to Halifax. To pay for the warm clothes he needs for the trip, Johnny decides to sell his silver cup. Thinking that he’ll get a better price from Mr. Lyte than from a silversmith who’ll melt it down, Johnny tries to sell the cup to the crooked merchant. Mr. Lyte snatches the cup, has his clerks block the boy’s escape, and calls for one of his captains to take him away from Boston on a ship.
Johnny escapes and races to the printing office. There, he meets Mr. Lorne, who is the owner and Rab’s uncle. Rab vouches for Johnny, so Mr. Lorne hires him on as a delivery boy even though Johnny has never ridden a horse before. In exchange for delivering papers in Boston and the surrounding towns, Mr. Lorne promises Johnny room and board. Rab takes Johnny to the stable and introduces him to Goblin, a fearful but beautiful pale horse with “a rich, blackish mahogany” mane, a matching tail, and “glassy blue” eyes (106). Rab gives Johnny a riding lesson on the Common where the militia practices their drills. This turns out to be Johnny’s first and only riding lesson as Rab is too busy for more. Undaunted, Johnny practices riding Goblin every day, and he basks in Uncle Lorne and Rab’s praise when he overhears them discussing his remarkable progress as an equestrian.
Johnny soon comes to enjoy his rides to the towns surrounding Boston. His interactions with Rab, Mr. Lorne, and the readers of The Boston Observer expand his interest in and knowledge of politics, and he becomes “an ardent Whig” (109). Johnny also settles into his new home with Rab in the printing shop’s loft. The loft serves as the meeting place for a powerful secret club of Whigs who call themselves the Boston Observers. Johnny’s delivery route for the printing office only takes three days, so he spends the rest of his week taking care of Goblin, teaching himself to write left-handed, and reading in Mr. Lorne’s extensive library. The boy devours everything from works of fiction like Robinson Crusoe to epics like Paradise Lost and the Iliad to essays on chemistry and philosophy. Rab’s aunt often brings Johnny freshly baked sweets when he’s reading, and she is very fond of the lonely boy. In particular, she is endeared by his futile attempts to hide how much he loves her infant son, whom Johnny nicknames Rabbit.
One Thursday, after Johnny finishes delivering his papers, he sees Cilla and Isannah fetching water in the town square. He commiserates with the girls when they describe how Mr. Tweedie has overturned their familiar routines. At first, Cilla responds stiffly to Johnny’s offer to meet her every Thursday and Sunday, thinking he is suggesting that she is too weak to carry water by herself. He explains that he misses her and Isannah. Cilla tells Johnny that she might meet him in the town square as he requested, and Johnny watches the girls head home with a lump in his throat.
Johnny idolizes Rab but is frustrated that he knows little more about the self-contained boy than he learned from their first meeting. Johnny is easily influenced by others’ perceptions of him, and Rab’s incisive questions about Johnny’s behavior encourage him to choose his words with more care. This change bears fruit when Sukey, a Black girl who works for Sam Adams, accidentally splashes him with dishwater. Johnny bites his tongue instead of telling her “what he thought of her” and “black folk in general” (116). Sukey brings him inside so she can dry his clothes, and Mr. Adams speaks with him from then on when he delivers the paper.
In the fall, Johnny attends a dance at the Lexington estate of Rab’s grandfather, who raised Rab after his parents died. Johnny reacts with surprise and slight disapproval when his friend casts off his usual nonchalance to dance with and charm the local girls. After the dance, Johnny mentions that his right hand didn’t seem to trouble the girls he danced with the way that it bothers the people in Boston. Rab replies that Johnny’s negative feelings toward his hand evoke those same feelings in others. Since Johnny wasn’t self-conscious of himself during the dance, his dancing partners thought nothing of his hand either.
A few days later, Johnny sees Rab step out of his dispassionate air again when the Webb twins, who work for the printing press, are bullied at a butcher’s shop. Johnny and Rab rescue the twins’ cat from the cruel butcher’s boy. The two of them take on four opponents in the ensuing scuffle, but Rab makes sure that he and Johnny are safely back in the printing office by the time the constable arrives. Johnny can tell that his friend enjoyed the brawl and wonders why someone so powerful avoids fighting. Aunt Lorne offers some answers by describing how her baby won’t fuss or indicate what’s bothering him, a trait she sees in her nephew and the other Silsbees. Johnny decides to accept Rab as he is instead of trying to puzzle out the enigmatic boy.
In November, tensions rise between England and the American colonies over a tax on tea. Although the tax itself has a negligible impact on the colonists’ finances, many object on principle to paying taxes to England when they are unable to elect representatives in the British government. Early one Sunday morning, Sam Adams comes to the printing office and says that the East India Company’s first shipload of tea nears Boston’s harbor on the Dartmouth. Mr. Lorne and Rab prepare 200 copies of a placard Adams penned, which exhorts the colonists “to make united and successful resistance to this last, worst, and most destructive measure of Administration” (125).
Adams asks Johnny to use a coded message to inform the Boston Observers of a meeting that night, and the boy is excited to have a hand in this rebellious, dangerous event. The secret society’s members include the Reverend Samuel Cooper, Mr. Hancock, Josiah Quincy, John Adams, Dr. Warren, and Paul Revere. Johnny sees Cilla and Isannah standing by the water pump in the town square and thinks they look rather shabby and pitiful. He hadn’t kept his promise to meet them in the past weeks, but he still feels bored listening to Cilla discuss the changes in the Lapham household. Johnny is frustrated by Cilla’s faithfulness toward him and by her ignorance of the ways he’s changed since he left the Laphams.
While the Boston Observers meet in the printing office’s loft, Johnny hears members of the Sons of Liberty beating up a lone Tory and feels sickened by the violence. As Johnny looks around at the men assembled in the attic, he realizes that they want war, not peace and compromise. If the governor does not make the East India Company’s ship return to England within 20 days, the Boston Observers plan to send a boarding party to dump the tea in the harbor on the night of December 16. After swearing the boys to secrecy, the Observers recruit Rab for the cause, and he promises to find other young men to join the boarding party. Rab wants Johnny to participate, and Johnny nervously lies awake. He also has trouble sleeping because he feels terrible for being so unkind to Cilla when he loves her. Seeking to emulate his friend’s calm, Johnny times his breathing to the sleeping Rab’s and manages to fall asleep.
Johnny practices chopping wood left-handed so he can be ready to smash the chests of tea with the rest of the boarding party. Through frequent meetings at the Old South Church, Sam Adams and his followers whip the city into a fury like the one that followed the Boston Massacre. The Eleanor and the Beaver join the Dartmouth in the harbor. The ships cannot leave while the tea is still onboard, but an order from the Town of Boston prevents them from unloading the controversial cargo. In addition, two British warships lie ready to destroy the vessels if they attempt to return to London with the tea. Armed citizens guard the ships day and night to ensure that no tea is smuggled ashore and no harm befalls the vessels.
On the night of December 16, a group of boys gathers in the printing office and prepares to board the three ships. They cover their faces in soot and put on disguises. Rab sends Johnny to the meeting at Old South Church, where Sam Adams uses a coded message to initiate the attack on the tea. At Adams’s words, the crowd of thousands erupts into a clamor of whistles, “Indian war whoops,” and cries of “Hi, Mohawks, get your axes and pay no taxes!” (145). An outwardly calm but inwardly exultant Rab awaits Johnny back in the printing office, and the boys race to the wharf. There, they meet thousands of men and boys in similar disguises, and the crowd divides into three boarding parties.
Rab and Johnny join the group led by Paul Revere and board the Dartmouth. The party works to destroy the chests of tea, but they make sure that they do not damage anything else. Johnny sees Dove trying to steal some of the cargo. This action would compromise the rebels’ moral high ground, so Johnny and Rab dump both the purloined tea and the would-be thief in the harbor. After the participants of the tea party return to shore, a British admiral warns them that there will be consequences for their actions.
In this section, Johnny finds a new life, albeit one far removed from the luxury and privilege he initially imagines. In Chapter 4, the silver cup becomes the center of a conspiracy that threatens the protagonist’s life. Johnny arrogantly ignores foreshadowing, and his pride results in disaster just as it did in Chapter 2. For example, he envisions himself lording his newfound wealth over the Laphams before he even meets with Mr. Lyte, and he ignores Rab’s warnings. During the meeting with Mr. Lyte, he insults the merchant and doesn’t question why Mr. Lyte wants him to come “an hour after candles are lit” (78). As a result, he falls for the merchant’s trap, surrenders his cup, and nearly loses his life.
Mr. Lyte acts as a sort of threshold guardian. The suspicious merchant believes that Johnny is lying about their kinship, so he prevents Johnny from claiming his rightful place among his mother’s family and the wealth and power that accompany that status. As a result of Mr. Lyte’s actions, the protagonist faces danger and must find a new way to survive in a changing world. Mr. Lyte’s betrayal and the trial dramatically reveal whom Johnny can trust. Before his meeting with the merchant, Rab offers Johnny wise counsel concerning Mr. Lyte’s character in addition to food, fresh clothes, and a place to sleep. It’s telling that Johnny asks the sheriff to inform Rab he’s been arrested, not the family he’s been staying with for the last two years. Johnny and Rab have only spoken twice at that point, but the protagonist already knows who his truest ally is. On the contrary, Mrs. Lapham, who praised and relied on Johnny in Chapter 1, is willing to stand by and let him hang in Chapter 4.
Rab shows great resourcefulness and generosity by interceding for Johnny again during his imprisonment and trial. The 16-year-old uses his connections with the Sons of Liberty to have his friend moved to a more comfortable cell and recruits an excellent lawyer. He also makes sure Cilla and Isannah are able to speak on Johnny’s behalf by pretending to have a letter from the governor. He cleverly repurposes the letter from the governor, which was actually a command for the printing office “to quit their seditious, rebellious publications” (99). In the quick-thinking rebel’s hands, this letter becomes a tool he can use to challenge the social order and defend his ideals. His deception of Mrs. Lapham reflects the Sons of Liberty’s effective and often extralegal methods. Although he is willing to resort to trickery to protect his friend’s life, Rab possesses a strong moral compass. He knows that Johnny is innocent, and he is an ardent defender of the truth.
Cilla and Isannah’s actions in Chapter 4 prove that they are also the protagonist’s allies. Cilla and Johnny still care for one another despite the change in her family’s plans regarding their marriage. She proves where her loyalties lie by openly defying her mother and appearing in court. Her force of will impresses Rab, who observes, “Well, may Priscilla be on my side if ever I’m accused of anything” (91). For all his protestations to Mrs. Lapham, Johnny clearly admires the girl and hasn’t abandoned the hope that they might be together either. In addition to pleading on Johnny’s behalf in court, Isannah makes amends for her cruel words in Chapter 3, and she furthers her apologies by kissing Johnny’s right hand.
In this section, Lavinia distances herself from the other members of the Lyte family, especially her father. She doesn’t go to the dining room where Johnny is arrested, and she sits away from her father at the trial. Her motivations remain a mystery at this point in the novel, but her words to Isannah outside of the courthouse foreshadow her later actions when she takes the young girl away from her family.
Johnny becomes much more interested in and involved with politics thanks to Rab’s influence. For example, the Sons of Liberty fascinate him once he learns that his friend is a member, and the Sons demonstrate their considerable power and connections by defeating the wealthy Mr. Lyte in court. Johnny learns more about Boston’s political landscape thanks to his job at the printing office, which he secures with Rab’s help. Printing becomes a motif that supports the theme of Self-Sacrifice for the Greater Good due to the importance of the printed word in spreading the cause of independence.
Forbes has the Whigs’ leaders meet within the printing office itself to reinforce this connection. As a newly minted Whig, Johnny grows more informed on political matters through discussions with the Boston Observer’s readers and the rebellion’s leaders. He even converses with Sam Adams, one of the most important figures in America’s struggle for independence. It should also be noted that it is Mrs. Lapham’s illiteracy that allows her to be fooled by Rab’s letter and Johnny’s ability to read that at least gets him a chance at Mr. Hancock’s shop. Though he was unsuccessful at finding work with Mr. Hancock, his ability to read is already setting him apart from people like Mrs. Lampham.
Johnny matures in other ways in this section, but he still has room for growth. He explores worlds beyond the one he’s known all his life by reading works of great literature, philosophy, and science in Mr. Lorne’s extensive library. He also learns to ride a horse, mostly by himself, which is a testament to his willpower. Thanks to Rab’s influence, he tries to hold his tongue instead of saying every hurtful thing he thinks of. This develops the theme of Learning Humility and Empathy because he accepts his friend’s criticism and tries to consider how his words affect others. For example, he holds his tongue when Sukey accidentally splashes him with water. The narrative immediately rewards him for this by inviting him into Sam Adams’s presence. While Johnny keeps his thoughts to himself in this scene, he doesn’t seem to examine why he had those racist thoughts in the first place or work to unlearn his prejudices.
After losing his place among the Laphams and being betrayed by his blood relatives, the Lytes, Johnny gains a new family—the unflappable Rab Silsbee, whom he admires so much; the generous Mr. Lorne; and the warmhearted Mrs. Lorne. Thanks to the warmth and safety of this new family, Johnny begins to emerge from his defensive shell and show love in his dutiful care for the timid Goblin and his fondness for little Rabbit Lorne. He also learns to accept Rab as he is rather than trying to unravel his enigmatic friend. That said, this section yields some more information about the self-contained 16-year-old. When he leaps to the Webb twins’ defense, Rab demonstrates his loathing for bullies and his willingness to fight for his ideals. These traits will become increasingly important as the novel goes on and war looms closer.
Of course, Johnny doesn’t want to break all of his ties to the Laphams, and he shows a newfound humility in his words to Cilla in Chapter 5. Cilla and Johnny are alike in that their dignity is important to them. He doesn’t want people to pity him because of his hand, and she doesn’t want him thinking that she’s too weak to fetch water. Johnny swallows some of his pride by admitting that he is lonely and homesick without her. However, Johnny soon breaks his promise to Cilla and feels irritated by her faithfulness. In Chapter 6, he feels guilty for his behavior toward her, considers her one of his best friends, and even thinks that he loves her. In later sections, he will have to work to undo the damage he’s caused their relationship.
In the span of a few months, Johnny goes from knowing little of politics to participating in one of the most famous acts of rebellion against British rule. His new proximity to intrigue and danger excites him, but he is sickened by the violence his side commits against the Tories. This inner conflict will continue throughout the novel as he struggles to reconcile his belief in liberty with the bloodshed that inevitably comes from fighting for freedom. Rab has no such reservations and comes “terrifyingly alive” on the night of the Boston Tea Party (146). Rab’s energy in Chapter 6 is somewhat comparable to the moments in Chapter 5 when dancing and fighting invigorate him, but Johnny senses a frightening change in his friend.
On the contrary, Dove’s brief appearance during the Boston Tea Party shows that he is as self-serving as ever. The incident allows Johnny to retaliate against the boy who ruined his promising future as a silversmith, but Johnny is acting in the interest of a cause bigger than himself rather than seeking petty revenge. The section ends on an ominous note with the admiral promising that the Boston Tea Party will have far-reaching consequences. In the next section, Johnny and everyone else in Boston will learn the truth of these words.
Action & Adventure
View Collection
American Revolution
View Collection
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Newbery Medal & Honor Books
View Collection
Required Reading Lists
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
War
View Collection