logo

49 pages 1 hour read

Lisa See

Lady Tan's Circle of Women

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Rice-and-Salt Days: The Third Through Fifth Years of the Hongzhi Emperor’s Reign (1490-1492)”

Part 3, Chapter 10 Summary: “The Wife Is Earth”

Yunxian is a busy wife and mother. She also provides medical treatments to women who consult her and writes down notes on her cases. She tends to her mother-in-law every morning, bringing Lady Kuo tea supplied by Meiling’s husband, Kailoo, who is a tea merchant. Lady Kuo has a distinct cough and Yunxian suspects what ails her, but Yunxian knows Lady Kuo will not accept treatments from her and so does not volunteer her assistance.

Yunxian now has three daughters and is 29, a year older than her mother when she died. Maoren passed his imperial exams and is often away. Her two elder daughters, Yuelan and Chunlan, help Yunxian bind the feet of the youngest daughter, Ailan, who is five. One out of every 10 girls dies during the footbinding process, but the Yang family has not lost any girls, thanks to Yunxian.

Yunxian visits her grandmother, who is aging. They discuss Yifeng, who is married and has four sons. Grandmother continues to help Yunxian grow in medical expertise. Yunxian continues to see Meiling in secret. Meiling has become a respected midwife but does not have a child, which saddens her. Meiling thinks Yunxian should write a book about her medical cases, but Yunxian does not seek fame. Meling convinces Yunxian to disguise herself and visit a woman, a bricklayer, who needs medical help. Yunxian is able to diagnose and prescribe a remedy for the bricklayer’s problem, which is due to exhaustion from overwork.

Back in the inner chambers, Yunxian notes how Manzi, now 13, is spoiled by Lady Kuo, almost as if he were her ritual son. Yunxian spends time with her daughters, supporting Ailan through her agony and thinking her pain will prepare her to be a valuable wife: “diligent, uncomplaining, and obedient” (188). Still, for all her industry, Yunxian feels exhausted and sad.

Part 3, Chapter 11 Summary: “The Hundred Pulses”

Maoren brings a high-ranking official to visit. The women of the inner chambers are fascinated by the official’s wife, Lady Liu, and her mother, Widow Bao. The official works for the emperor, seeking boys and men to become eunuchs in the imperial palace. Widow Bao has heard Yunxian is a doctor for women and describes the illness of her other daughter, who has lost both her children. Yunxian suggests a remedy for the daughter’s depression, and for Widow Bao, who is going through menopause. The visiting women observe Meiling while she attends a young wife who is in pain because she just gave birth and is neglected by her husband.

Despite trying, Yunxian is not able to conceive a son. Lady Kuo arranges to buy Maoren a concubine. The girl is 14 and named Snowpink. Yunxian feels sad and defeated.

Part 3, Chapter 12 Summary: “A Snake Always Sheds Its Skin”

Meiling is summoned to serve as midwife at the imperial palace, and Yunxian helps her prepare for the journey to Beijing. Maoren scolds Yunxian because Meiling, and not their family, has been elevated by their visitors.

Three months later, Yunxian is summoned to Beijing to treat a woman with an eye infection. Yunxian says she cannot go as she is pregnant, but Maoren insists she take this opportunity. Miss Zhao and Poppy travel with her. Yunxian treats the woman who steers the boat, who appears to have symptoms of neurological damage.

After five weeks of travel, Yunxian arrives at the Forbidden City. They are escorted into the Great Within, the inner chambers for the imperial women. Meiling welcomes them, and Yunxian sees she is pregnant. The woman Yunxian has been called to attend is the empress.

Part 3, Chapter 13 Summary: “The Great Within”

The Hongzhi emperor has no concubines and only one wife: Empress Zhang. Yunxian is nervous about treating her, but after her eye infection clears up, the empress decides she wants a woman doctor to attend her childbirth. Both Yunxian and Meiling will have to stay in Beijing. They take comfort in one another’s company and imagine their children will grow up together.

Yunxian doctors Meiling through her pregnancy and is concerned when Meiling experiences severe morning sickness. When the empress goes into labor, so does Meiling. Meiling insists on staying to attend to the empress, who gives birth to a boy. Before Meiling can leave the room, she delivers a stillborn daughter. Meiling is devastated.

Part 3, Chapter 14 Summary: “Blood”

Yunxian tends Meiling, who has lost a great deal of blood. Meiling is seized and brought before the emperor, accused of offending the empress and polluting her chambers. The emperor orders that Meiling be put to death, but the empress intercedes. Yunxian pleads on Meiling’s behalf, and so do the other women present. The sentence is commuted to a flogging.

When Meiling is brought back to her rooms, beaten and bleeding, Yunxian violates the taboo on touching blood to wash and tend her. She cuts a vein in her wrist and mixes her own blood into a healing tea. A doctor who treats war wounds advises Yunxian to use spiderwebs to close the wounds on Meiling’s back. Meiling’s emotions need healing as well, and Yunxian is distressed that she missed the signs that something was wrong.

Part 3, Chapter 15 Summary: “Life Without a Friend…”

Yunxian weeps tears of joy when she at last gives birth to a son. She prepares to return home with her son and Meiling. The empress sends Yunxian many gifts, which Yunxian plans to share with Meiling. They ride with the same tiller woman, who has improved thanks to Yunxian’s prescription.

Meiling confesses that she took the preparation Doctor Wong sent Yunxian for her pregnancy. She feels guilty for stealing, but when she describes the ingredients, Yunxian recognizes several abortifacients—ingredients that would cause a miscarriage. They arrive home, and Yunxian promises she will visit Meiling.

Part 3, Chapter 16 Summary: “A Sapling in a Typhoon”

Smallpox has struck the Garden of Fragrant Delights. Lady Kuo asks Yunxian to help. Yunxian gives her son, Lian, to a wetnurse and goes to the garden, where the sick have been taken. Miss Chen is among them, along with her son, Manzi, and Yunxian’s daughter, Ailan. Snowpink, the concubine, and her infant son die despite Yunxian’s tending. Yunxian toils to help the afflicted, though she feels she is failing at every death. Miss Chen assists. Doctor Wong stays away.

Grandmother Ru arrives to help, along with Miss Zhao, and Yunxian takes heart as Ailan recovers. Grandmother Ru wonders why Doctor Wong would prescribe Yunxian a tea that would cause a miscarriage. She reminds Yunxian of how she once treated a “ghost pregnancy”—a pregnancy that occurs in widows or wives and concubines whose husbands and masters are far from home. While Yunxian thinks that anger is the emotion most often at the root of women’s illnesses, Grandmother reflects that sadness was at the heart of the affliction that killed Yunxian’s mother. Grieved over the loss of her sons, she neglected to care for her damaged feet and so took infection and died.

Manzi dies from smallpox, and Yunxian realizes he doesn’t resemble Master Yang. She remembers how Spinster Aunt wanted to tell Yunxian something the night before she died and concludes that Manzi’s father was someone else.

Part 3, Chapter 17 Summary: “The Washing Away of Wrongs”

After the smallpox threat is over, Miss Chen is sent away with her last surviving child. Yunxian visits Meiling and discusses her suspicions. Midwife Shi, Meiling’s mother, confirms that, at his birth, Miss Chen identified Doctor Wong as Manzi’s father. Yunxian writes to her father, now a high-ranking magistrate, who arrives to conduct an inquiry.

Her father-in-law and husband scold her again, but Yunxian is prepared to give her evidence. Spinster Aunt’s body is exhumed and the fracture on her skull indicates that she was struck from behind. Witnesses locate the rock that cracked her skull. Meiling describes the remedy she took in Beijing and the miscarriage that resulted. Poppy reveals that she was instructed by Doctor Wong to make the remedy for Yunxian.

Doctor Wong protests that a magistrate should not be swayed by the mutterings of women. Then, Midwife Shi testifies that Miss Chen identified Doctor Wong as being Manzi’s father. Spinster Aunt knew this also. Doctor Wong confesses that he conspired with Miss Chen to have a son who would rule the Yang household, and he meant for Yunxian to miscarry so she could not have a son to rival Manzi.

Maoren is not pleased at the family scandal, but Yunxian’s father is proud of what Yunxian has accomplished as a doctor. When Yunxian is frustrated that her father did not call all possible witnesses, he warns Yunxian to consider who else might have conspired with Miss Chen to produce a son for the Yang family.

Part 3, Chapter 18 Summary: “At the Border of the Sky”

Yunxian visits her grandmother, who is dying from a tumor in her breast. Grandmother bequeaths Yunxian her books and medical supplies. Yunxian stays until her grandmother passes, then performs the duties necessary to prepare and inter the body and observe the mourning rites.

When she returns home, Yunxian becomes ill and experiences delirium. She dreams that Grandmother visits and chides Yunxian for giving in to melancholy, which has always been her weakness. The ghost of Grandmother tells Yunxian that she encouraged her friendship with Meiling to provide yang to balance Yunxian’s yin. Grandmother tells Yunxian exactly where in her casebook to look for a remedy. Grandmother thinks that a doctor who has experienced illness can treat her patients with better understanding.

Yunxian finds the remedy, and Meiling helps her prepare it. Yunxian heals. When she is well, Yunxian confronts her mother-in-law. Lady Kuo confesses that she instructed Doctor Wong and Miss Chen to give her a ritual son in case something happened to Maoren. Lady Kuo insists that everything she has done has been to make sure the family endures, and she has been training Yunxian to take up this same responsibility. She did not expect Doctor Wong to become ambitious and try to harm Yunxian, however. Seeking forgiveness, Lady Kuo says she will approve of Yunxian practicing medicine, but only inside the compound. She asks Yunxian to treat her, and Yunxian extracts an enormous tapeworm from Lady Kuo’s intestines.

Next, Yunxian prepares remedies that help Meiling conceive again. She prepares her daughter, Yuelan, for her marriage. She locates Miss Chen and helps find customers for Miss Chen’s embroidery skills so she can support herself and her daughter. Meiling gives birth to a healthy son. Reflecting that she is 31 years of age, with many rice-and-salt years ahead of her, Yunxian resolves to use what her grandmother taught her to “heal women. Without fear. Without hesitation” (320).

Part 3 Analysis

Now in the third part of her life, Yunxian finds herself challenged by balancing her interests as a wife, mother, daughter-in-law, and doctor. Unlike the secluded life of leisure and learning that she knew before, she is now in a sense a working woman, though she does not earn pay. She is acting on her wish to help women, though doing so without Lady Kuo’s approval. As her family grows, along with her patients and her list of recorded cases, Yunxian feels taxed by the many demands upon her. The bricklayer who is overworked by her husband’s absences and the young wife who feels neglected by her husband are both foils for and parallels to Yunxian, highlighting The Subordinate Status of Women. Meiling continues to provide her balance and support as they share similar struggles: the demands of their professions, caring for a household, and longing to have a son.

Yunxian fulfills this all-important duty of bearing a son, but does so under difficult circumstances and, it turns out, despite the interference of Doctor Wong, whose ambitions for his own son lead him to commit harm. Meiling’s miscarriage and then torture by the emperor provide a vivid example of how the culture’s values and traditions harm women physically and mentally. Doctor Wong wants the same thing that the women of the inner chambers want—security in his own position, and a secure place for his son—but his self-interest stands in direct contrast to the motives of Yunxian, who helps women of all classes for their own benefit, not her fame.

Nowhere are these contradicting motives more evident than in the two doctors’ reactions to the smallpox epidemic at the Garden of Fragrant Delights. Yunxian, who has had the disease and therefore cannot contract it again, surrenders care of her infant son so she might use her skills to help those suffering—which includes her rivals, Miss Chen and Manzi and Snowpink and her son. While cultural values might demand that she put her son before everything else, Yunxian plunges into the sick ward to devote herself to her youngest daughter, the one child who has not yet been variolated (the procedure that introduces a small portion of the smallpox virus, thus inoculating the person against contracting the disease). Doctor Wong doesn’t come near the garden. He doesn’t want his reputation damaged by the deaths that will surely result. Yunxian feels the loss of each person she cannot save as a personal grief.

Despite her strong sense of duty and obligation to tradition, as demonstrated by her obedience to Lady Kuo and binding her daughters’ feet, Yunxian shows independence of mind when dealing with male authorities, confronting The Conflict Between Tradition and Ambition. She is aware of her culture’s values but is not cowed by them. She contacts her father to bring an accusation against Doctor Wong, hoping her father will be fair and dispense proper justice. She dares to speak before the emperor, asking the empress to intercede and lessen Meiling’s punishment. Yunxian obeys her husband in traveling to Beijing when she would have rather stayed home, and risks her own health and pregnancy. However, in doing so, she shows her personal commitment to advancing and protecting her family, just as she takes action to provide medical care when smallpox invades. Yunxian was born in the year of the Snake, and she uses the imagery and qualities associated with this image to describe herself: She is adaptable, shedding her skin when necessary to rise to the situation at hand.

Yunxian’s step forward into claiming her own authority is further demonstrated when she treats Lady Kuo, who has been plagued by a parasite. The tapeworm represents the fears that Lady Kuo has long nurtured about the future prospects of the Yang family. These fears led her to manipulate Doctor Wong and Miss Chen into passing Manzi off as Master Yang’s child; to remain silent even when she might have suspected Doctor Wong played a part in Spinster Aunt’s death; and to prohibit Yunxian from behaving outside the ideals of propriety and usurping Doctor Wong’s authority in providing medical care to their household. In extracting the tapeworm, just as she urged the new inquest that revealed the truth, Yunxian brings to light the poisonous secrets and achieves healing for all involved.

While male and familial authorities often prove negligent, stern, or downright threatening to women’s health and livelihoods, Yunxian’s circle of women grows in strength and support, reinforcing The Power of Women’s Alliances. She extends her circle with the women she treats; she does not hesitate to help women of a lower social class, showing the same care for the empress that she shows to the bricklayer and the tiller who steers her boat. Miss Zhao, Grandmother Ru, Poppy, and Meiling all continue to be supports in this circle, and Yunxian cares for their well-being in return.

When she tends to Meiling’s wounds from the miscarriage and flogging, Yunxian puts aside the cultural taboos on her position to treat her friend with her own hands, showing that she no longer regards these distinctions as necessary. Her adding her own blood to Meiling’s tea contains important symbolism. Medically-speaking, Yunxian believes that consuming blood will strengthen Meiling by supplying the element in which she is deficient. In a more symbolic sense, wounding herself to provide her own blood to heal Meiling shows how deeply Yunxian values her friend’s life. Their bond, which continues to strengthen and evolve, is now sealed by blood ties.

While Lady Kuo continues to uphold the values of tradition and propriety, Grandmother Ru continues to expand opportunities for Yunxian. She confers her knowledge and supplies on Yunxian, showing that she sanctions her granddaughter’s practice of this traditional medicine that has been handed down in the family. Her visitation in Yunxian’s delirium can be read as an actual visit by a ghost, but It can also be read as Yunxian visualizing her grandmother as the wiser part of herself—the wiser self that Yunxian has become as a mother, by treating the patients she has, by learning what she knows. Her ability to locate her own remedy shows that Yunxian is now fully matured into her practice and into self-knowledge. She has truly stepped into Grandmother Ru’s legacy and claimed her power, but is able to do so because of the women who in turn treat and heal her, tend her wounds, and balance her needs.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text