logo

72 pages 2 hours read

Jack Mayer

Life in a Jar: The Irena Sendler Project

Nonfiction | Book | Middle Grade | Published in 2005

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 2, Chapters 8-10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2

Chapter 8 Summary: “Invasion: Warsaw, September 1939”

Part 2 takes place in Warsaw, beginning just prior to the German invasion of Poland. Irena Sendler is woken up by explosions shaking her whole building, followed closely by her mother pounding on her door to get her down to the bomb shelter. Her thoughts shift briefly to her husband, Mietek, a lieutenant in the Polish army, despite her knowledge that their marriage had essentially run its course. After the all-clear an hour later, Irena dresses and leaves for work at the Social Welfare office, joining the “sparse but confused rush hour of Warsovians trying to live normally on the first day of war” (67).

“The two Irenas,” Sendler and her coworker Schultz, use their positions to engage in welfare fraud in order to assist their Jewish clients. During another bombing raid, the two discuss whether or not to trust their boss, Jan Dobraczynski; Irena Schultz believes that they will soon have to as the situation in Warsaw worsens. The two Irenas had themselves met due to a matter of trust. Irena Sendler had been falsifying documents in order to assist Jewish and Romani clients; Irena Schultz, her superior, had noticed the alterations, but instead of reporting her or firing her, told her: “Next time, only change the year,” rather than the full birthdate, as “[t]hat’s an honest, careless mistake” (71), unlikely to be noticed. They had also previously worked with another social worker, Ewa Rechtman, to bring supplies into the Jewish districts. However, Ewa was fired “during the winter of 1938-1939, when the Polish government had decreed that all Jewish Welfare workers employed by the state were to be terminated” (73).

Following the all-clear and an impromptu rendition of the Polish national anthem, Jan sends everyone home for the day. The two Irenas walk through the rubble of Warsaw together, past immobilized trams and “smoldering ruins that yesterday had been a three-story building with shops,” with the dead “laid out on the street, awaiting the morgue wagon” (74).

In the next few days, things escalate. All able-bodied men are called to the lines to defend against the oncoming German army; shortly after, martial law is declared, and citizens are evacuated and ordered to use anything they can to form a barricade. Irena is “most distressed to see her books, once so dignified in her bookcase, now flotsam and jetsam strewn over a crude barrier erected to stop a German tank” (76). In defiance of the order, back in her apartment that night, her mind jumps between her husband, Mietek; her mother; and her dear friend, and future husband, Stefan.

As the Germans advance, Irena continues to walk to work daily, as it “offer[s][her] a sense of purpose” (77). One day, Jan and Jaga, his assistant, step into Irena’s office under the pretense of assisting her with an influx of additional responsibilities. However, their real purpose is to provide her with blank papers—birth certificates, baptismal certificates, marriage licenses, etc.—in order to help as many Jewish families as she can through her “creative social work” (77); this ensures Irena that she can trust Jan and Jaga.

Irena sets up a network of trusted social workers throughout the 10 district Social Welfare offices through and with whom she can assist families with “false documents” (79). One day, she discovers that it is “relatively simple” (79) to forge Jan’s signature for money and food vouchers, which adds to her repertoire of assistance.

In late September, Warsaw surrenders to Germany. That evening, she walks “home through her ravaged city, the sky furnace-red,” thinking about how “someday an historian would write about this time and would tell it all wrong, because nothing written or explained logically could ever capture what Warsaw endured” (80)through the siege.

After her firing, Ewa went to CENTOS, a Jewish “self-help” charity. Irena continues to visit Ewa frequently, and Ewa’s “natural optimism and persistent smile” continue to be “a relief for Irena, an oasis of hope” (80). On her way back from Ewa’s office at one point, Irena encounters soldiers and asks after her husband; she’s told only that he is one of the “good ones” (82), although they don’t know if he is alive or dead.

Chapter 9 Summary: “Bread Lines: Warsaw, October 1939–January 1940”

With Poland’s surrender, Stefan returns to Warsaw and Irena resumes her home visits for work. As the two walk together, they see “two men [cutting] gray meat from a dead horse” (84). Irena notes that the meat might be tainted; Stefan responds: “It might not be tainted. Starving people will eat almost anything” (84). Polish radio and mainstream publications had gone silent two weeks earlier, but underground radio from Berlin, Moscow, London, and Paris were still coming into Warsaw, with each reporting “a different war” (85).

Irena’s mother returns to their apartment. One night, Janina is looking through old photographs when Irena joins her. Looking at one of their family, she tells Irena that she misses Irena’s father and “just want[s] to die peacefully” (85).

On September 28, 1939, Germany takes control and begins a series of rapid-fire decrees that slowly erode the rights of the Jewish population. By the beginning of October, the Wehrmacht has arrived. On October 5, Adolph Hitler arrives “to celebrate [the German] victory” (86), although civilians either avoid the Germans or watch through their windows.

The Germans’ first official act is “one of kindness; the army [doles] out warm soup and black bread” (86). As Stefan and Irena pass a soup line, someone further back accuses someone toward the front of being Jewish. Two SS officers pull the people out of the line; Irena wants to help, but Stefan tells her to keep walking. Moments later, the SS officers shoot the Jewish couple.

This makes Irena think of “her parents’ injunction to stand up for those treated unjustly” (87). She recalls a classmate from her school days, Rachela, the only Jewish girl in her class. One day, two larger girls attacked Rachela; without thinking, Irena stepped in to help. A right-wing teacher promised her she would be punished, but after describing the incident to another teacher, she was told she did the right thing and was let go: “After this incident some students became openly hostile to Irena, calling her ‘Jew slave’ and “Rachela’s secret sister’” (88).

Later, toward the end of high school, the same right-wing teacher, “Pika,” tried to fail her for a paper she wrote arguing that “growing political chaos and the splintering of parties, accompanied by inflation, led to the scapegoating of minorities by the nationalist right” (88). A failure would have prevented her from moving on to university: “In the course of her research, Irena read everything she could about anti-Semitism in Poland. She was bewildered by the conflicting reasons given for loathing the Jews, often by the same parties or groups” (88). Another instructor once again saved her, Headmaster Pan Wyszinski, who replaced her grade with a B+. However, he also warned her that “[m]any academics at Warsaw University share [Pika’s] political views” (89), telling her she shouldn’t step out of line.

Nevertheless, at university, she did. Students and professors, in part due to Hitler’s rhetoric, became openly hostile toward Jewish students, throwing one “Jewish girl through a second story window”(90), after which the university did nothing. Jews were made to sit on separate benches in classes, and their exam books were marked “JEW.” Irena began sitting with the Jewish students and writing “JEW” on her own exam books. As a result, she was suspended from the university.

Back with Stefan in Warsaw, the two argue over the couple. Irena argues that she “can’t be a bystander” (91). Stefan responds that in university, “it meant a disciplinary suspension, now it means a bullet in your head” (91).

Upon arriving at work, she discovers from someone that five buildings were forced out, suddenly, at gunpoint. Irena takes the man to see Jan, who repeats that he cannot tell the Germans what to do and cannot do anything himself. Irena believes that Jan is correct but is acting harshly toward the man; she “[shares] his frustration and maybe his anxiety as well, with how quickly conditions in Warsaw had deteriorated. And there [is] little any of them could do about it” (92).

Chapter 10 Summary: “Decrees: Warsaw, October 1939–January 1940”

Irena continues to seek out information about her husband. She and Mietek had grown up together and gone to the same university; they had married in 1931, shortly before her suspension: “Ironically, their marriage’s demise began as a stroke of good fortune for Mietek” (93), who was offered a teaching position in another city. He assumed she would join him, but she declined, choosing instead to focus on social work and overturning her university suspension: “In the end, Mietek went to Poznan. He wanted a wife; Irena wanted to change the world” (93). In early October, Irena receives a letter from Mietek, who is a prisoner of war.

German decrees continue to erode the rights of Jews in Warsaw. By the end of October, Jews have had their bank accounts frozen, their wages minimized, and their benefits forbidden. They are also obliged to work in “forced labor teams” (94).When Irena visits Ewa one day, Ewa’s brother Adam instead answers the door, and they meet for the first time. When Ewa appears and Adam disappears, Ewa tells Irena that her brother had been picked randomly up a few days earlier for forced labor. The worst part of it, she tells Irena, was the humiliation: “He said he would kill them. He means it. I see it in his eyes” (95).

Also in October, the first barbed wire enclosures begin to appear, closing off the Jewish population: “Despite the Germans’ obsessive fear of contagion and disease, especially typhus, they had created in the Jewish district the ideal conditions for pestilence […] overcrowding, poor sanitation, rodents, and malnutrition” (96). Irena accompanies Jan to a meeting with the head of the German Epidemic Control Authority, who argues that “Jews in particular carry and spread typhus” (96), putting Warsaw at risk if not for quarantine. Irena thinks that his “idiocy would cost lives—but maybe that was the point” (96). However, she also realizes that the Germans’ fear of typhus and tuberculosis provides an opportunity for her to help her clients.

On October 20, 1939, a decree is issued that all radios must be surrendered. However, Irena convinces her mother not to give theirs up, but instead to hide it in the attic, as she believes it might be useful one day.

Stefan, who walks Irena home most days for safety, begins to attend underground meetings of the Polish Socialist Party. Prior to the war, they used to argue about such meetings, and he again claims that it’s “[a] lot of talking. Something Jews and Socialists do all the time” (98). She chastises him, saying that he can pick on socialists because he is one, but that he shouldn’t speak ill of Jews. He responds by taking out his papers to show her the “JUDE” stamp. As it turns out, his family was Jewish, but converted to Christianity when he was a child; however, the Germans found out and still consider him to be Jewish. He remarks that he is “a chameleon, changing form Jew to Evangelical and now to Jew again” (100). Stefan continues: “I’m thinking of changing yet again. Maybe next time I’ll be a Catholic” (100).

By the end of November, all Jews are required to wear armbands with the Star of David on them, and all Jewish shops must likewise place the star at the entrance. Stefan’s newly forged papers allow him to avoid the armband, but those with armbands face severe mistreatment and violence. In December, a new spate of decrees is issued: selling bread at higher-than-pre-war prices will result in execution; Jewish schools are closed; prayer in synagogues is forbidden; and secret radios, like the one Irena hid, become punishable by death. Food rations also begin:“Germans receives 2,613 calories daily. Jews only 184; the only way Jews could stay alive was to buy black market or stolen food at five to ten times pre-war prices” (102).

Chapters 8-10 Analysis

Part 1 developed the mythos surrounding Irena. She began the novel as a mysterious, unknown savior. Her story, though still sparse, slowly formed through the girls’ research. However, by the end of the first part, the question of what became of Irena Sendler remained unresolved. Instead of answering this question outright, the reader is brought into the midst of Irena’s full story, realizing her as a person. In doing so, the novel removes some of the mythos in order to emphasize the power of the individual to right wrongs, and this is a constant refrain through these first few chapters. Irena’s parents were both members of resistance movements, and even before the war, Irena insisted on standing up for the powerless and oppressed around her. Even her work at the Social Welfare Office began first with her own individual act of resistance, as she took it upon herself to forge documents to aid Jewish families.

However, if it were not for luck and a likeminded individual in Irena Schultz, Irena Sendler would likely have been jailed for those forgeries; and, in fact, the power of the individual in the novel is consistently juxtaposed against the necessity of community. Not only do the two Irenas work together, but they rely on the complicity—explicit or implicit—of Jaga and Jan. Similarly, Irena is saved from tight spots twice by sympathetic figures, and when she is ultimately suspended from the university, it is precisely because there is no one there to get her out of it. Likewise, in her husband Mietek’s absence, she leans on Stefan—and eventually marries and raises children with him.

The rapid decline of Warsaw is nowhere more present than in the decrees issued from the end of September through December, which begin by guaranteeing basic rights, including to Jews. By December, the decrees have Jews limited to just 184 calories daily while being subjected to forced labor and humiliation in 10-hour days. Irena’s high school paper noted the contradictions inherent in the rhetoric about Jews, and the decrees offer evidence in action. One of the more puzzling decrees makes the sale of goods above pre-war prices punishable by death, and it seems strange that such a small thing would incur such a harsh punishment, until one realizes that the only way for Jews to survive is to buy black-market goods at “five to ten times pre-war prices” (102). The punishing pace of the decrees is certainly designed to confuse, but the content of the decrees seems to be even more so designed to create an impossible situation—Irena puzzles at the Germans’ placement of Jews in quarantine, which she believes will spread the very disease they wish to eradicate, then off-handedly wonders if that’s the point.

Of course, given hindsight and history lessons, the reader knows that it is precisely the point. In the moment, though, there is still vast disagreement, and many, like Irena, either wish to give some benefit of the doubt or else simply can’t believe that the Germans could be so evil. Ewa and Adam embody this difference. Ewa understands that the Germans are not benevolent and believes that they mean “only” to make Jews suffer, not eradicate them, whereas Adam is ready for violence in retribution. This thread will continue through the novel until Ewa’s death, and it mirrors the same debate taking place on a larger scale, as many in the global community at the time refused to believe what was evident all along—not necessarily out of a desire to see good in the Germans, but out of a desire not to see the depths to which tyrants descend.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text