63 pages • 2 hours read
Martha Hall KellyA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
In the spring of 1959, all the women meet in San Francisco. Janina joins them from France. They begin making their way to Los Angeles and the women tour the city and go to Disneyland. Caroline films it all with her camera. None of the women liked the child-sized train ride in Disneyland. After California, they visit the Grand Canyon, Las Vegas, Washington D.C., and finally Zuzanna and Kasia return to New York City. Zuzanna has been recovering faster than ever. At an automat in New York, Zuzanna asks for Kasia to help her choose a child from a dossier of orphans for her to adopt with Serge. Zuzanna has been asked by the hospital to teach a class and she wants to marry Serge. Kasia is furious and she says that their mother never would have wanted Zuzanna to marry a Russian cook and turn her back on Lublin. Zuzanna chooses to forgive and forget.
Early one morning, Kasia wakes and finds Caroline weeding. They admire the flowers together, Abraham Lincoln lilacs that only blossom after a particularly harsh winter. Kasia tears up at the thought. Kasia thanks Caroline for helping Zuzanna in ways that she could not. Eventually, Caroline tells Kasia that Herta Oberheuser had been granted an early release in 1952. Caroline needs someone to make a positive ID of Herta; they believe her to be practicing as a family doctor again in Stocksee, Germany. Caroline wants Kasia to take a photo of Herta to prove that she has been released. Kasia reacts to this request with fury; she has sacrificed enough.
Pietrik has moved the family to their own apartment when Kasia returns. It is small but it is theirs. Kasia feels much better with her new tooth and her fixed leg. She hopes that she will be able to mend the rift between her and Pietrik. Caroline gets the necessary money and documents to Kasia as promised; the choice to find Herta Oberheuser will be Kasia’s and Kasia’s alone. Zuzanna also sends a letter. Kasia’s daughter Halina has an art show that day but she does not wish to attend. Pietrik throws pebbles up at the kitchen window to get Kasia’s attention; he asks her to come down and play with him. Pietrik comes upstairs and tries to kiss her, more like the boy he used to be before the war, but Kasia turns away.
Pietrik asks about the package and Kasia tells him everything. Pietrik encourages Kasia to go; he says that he will go with her. Pietrik wants Kasia to move on, to love their daughter the way she deserves to be loved. Kasia goes to Halina’s art show and gets drunk. She cries when she sees Halina’s self-portrait; Kasia sees only her mother. The sight of Pietrik speaking with another woman upsets her as well. Pietrik tries to take Kasia home, but Halina’s teacher comes to join them, as does Papa and Marthe. Kasia goes on a drunken rant about her mother before Pietrik helps her home.
The next morning, Kasia readies herself to leave for Stocksee. She watches Pietrik sleep but is unable to find the courage to crawl into bed with him. Instead, Kasia goes through the package and finds what she needs. She leaves a note saying goodbye to Pietrik before leaving. Kasia drives for a long time and makes it to Germany the next day. The chapter ends with Kasia at the border, an East German soldier ordering her to get out of the car as her travel papers have been impounded.
Kasia’s papers have been replaced with a one-day pass. If she is not back past the border by six o’clock the next morning, she will be incarcerated. Kasia continues to drive for a long time before she arrives in Stocksee. There, she sees a silver Mercedes-Benz park in front of a small doctor’s office; Herta Oberheuser emerges from it and enters the building. Kasia makes an appointment with Herta. She is the last patient of the day and she considers leaving before the receptionist calls her into the back.
Serge and Zuzanna are married on October 25, 1959, on the grounds of Caroline’s Connecticut home. The bride and groom are beautiful in their respective luxurious outfits, as is their 10-month-old adopted son named Julien. Serge and Zuzanna have opened a French restaurant together; Zuzanna’s Polish desserts keep patrons coming back. Betty and Caroline both chat, happy for their friends, but cognizant that Zuzanna must miss her family terribly. Caroline, a group of British doctors, and Anise, one of the ladies from Ravensbrück who helped Janina and Kasia, wait for news about Herta Oberheuser; they are all ready to call for Herta’s medical license to be revoked.
Betty gives Caroline a gift: all the Woolsey silver that Caroline sold to Mr. Snyder to help her causes. Betty has been buying them for years and Caroline hugs her tightly, grateful to have such a kind friend. Earl arrives with a letter from Paul and a telegram from Kasia telling them that she has gone to Stocksee. Upon hearing that Kasia has gone to confront Herta on her own, Zuzanna takes Julien to the playhouse on the edge of the premises to be alone.
The receptionist leaves after handing Kasia her receipt. Herta does not recognize Kasia at all. Kasia tells Herta that she was once a prisoner at Ravensbrück; Herta denies any recollection of a Halina Kuzmerick. Kasia demands to know what happened to her mother. Kasia then notices her mother’s ring on Herta’s hand; Herta lies and says that the ring has been in her family for years. Kasia threatens to tell all the newspapers and everyone who will listen about everything Herta has done. Herta finally admits that Kasia’s mother was caught trying to edit the list of people chosen for surgeries. Halina attempted to take Kasia, Suzanna, and Luiza off the list. Halina had also been caught stealing coal to make remedies for the patients with dysentery. Otto Poll, one of the guards, was ordered to shoot Halina at the wall. Halina was allowed to see Zuzanna and Kasia one last time; Otto and Halina both cried, even when his gun jammed. Otto finally shot Halina when she wasn’t expecting it. Kasia asked Herta if she would have taken them off the list if she’d known they were Halina’s daughters, but Herta says nothing.
Kasia thanks her for telling the story and demands the ring back. She works the ring off Herta’s finger, cleans it, and puts it on her own. Herta tells Kasia that she would bring Halina back if she could. Kasia leaves, finally knowing what happened to her mother. She sends a telegram to Pietrik telling him that she will be home soon and another to Caroline: “Positively Herta Oberheuser. No doubt” (423). Kasia rips up the letter she was drafting to the paper. She knows Caroline will take care of Herta; the deep well of rage in Kasia had finally calmed.
Kasia returns home, lightness in her chest. Kasia gives her daughter the precious collection of her mother’s brushes before slipping into bed naked with Pietrik. He pulls Kasia close and she feels whole for the first time since before the war.
The final section of the novel provides a catharsis and resolution for Kasia and Caroline. Most notably, Kasia finally discovers the truth of her mother’s death and is finally able to accept and process her death. The symbolic recovery of her mother’s ring from Herta returns a piece of her to Kasia. Kasia has clung so fervently to every ounce of pain, anger, and hatred as they were the only things she had left to remind her of her mother. Halina, Kasia’s daughter, became a haunting image of her grandmother rather than a promise for the future. By confronting Herta, Kasia is given closure that she never had before. Kasia’s anger, fueled for over 10 years, has finally ebbed. Her mother had the opportunity to say goodbye and now Kasia knows that “the dream kiss had been real” (423). This is made especially clear when Kasia is no longer interested in finishing her letter to the newspaper; she is suddenly overcome with the urge to go home:
I cranked my window down and let the scent of autumn run around the inside of the dark car, the smell of fresh-mown hay taking me back to Deer Meadow, to thoughts of Pietrik warm beside me, to him holding baby Halina at the breakfast table, reading the newspaper with the bundle of her in his arms. Not letting her go. How easy it is to get tangled up in your own fishing net (423).
It is telling that Kasia is able to find joy in thoughts of the present, in Halina and Pietrik who wait for her at home, instead of her childhood memories before the war. The above passage also displays how Kasia has realized her own rage was a form of entrapment. Kasia now realizes everything that she has been keeping herself from. The end of the book is also a new beginning for Kasia. She is finally able to see Halina as her daughter rather than the image of her dead mother. Kasia is also finally able to be intimate with Pietrik, to be vulnerable and thus made whole by him.
While the readers are not explicitly told that Caroline and Paul have rekindled their relationship, the possibility for their love is stronger than it has been in the past:
I glanced at it just long enough to see Paul’s handwriting and tucked it in my apron pocket. I ran my fingers across the letter there and felt it was thick. A good sign. Was it simply a coincidence that Pan Am had recently started direct flights from New York to Paris? (414).
Caroline thus opens herself back up to love. Not entirely unlike Kasia’s refusal to let anyone in, Caroline has finally read his letters and possibly, begun to write back herself.
Kelly ends the novel with joy, hope, and possibility. She does not erase the scars of the past. For example, Zuzanna is still unable to conceive and yet, she has a son. Zuzanna and Serge adopt a boy named Julien, giving them all new beginnings that do not erase their pasts but instead, better their futures.