47 pages • 1 hour read
Mary KubicaA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Most of the characters either have a secret to keep or are lied to by someone that does. Meredith keeps secrets from Josh, Bea keeps secrets from Kate, Marty keeps secrets from Cassandra, who in turn keeps secrets from Meredith. Even young Leo is initiated into the world of secret-keeping when he makes a shushing sound and holds a finger to his lips when Meredith asks him what happens at Charlotte’s house, suggesting that his bully told him not to tell.
Most secrets serve, or are at least intended, to protect someone from something, whether the motives of the secret-keeper are selfish or benevolent. Secrets fester and become more problematic the longer they are kept; for instance, when Cassandra finds out that Meredith and Marty knew each other, she assumes that they are currently having an affair because they didn’t disclose that they had dated.
Most significant is Bea and Meredith’s secret of killing Shelby and hiding the body. Bea kills Meredith and kidnaps Delilah to keep this hidden. By suggesting that secrets are the norm rather than the exception, Kubica critiques The Oppressive Suburban Environment.
Driving and car accidents feature prominently in several key scenes. Early on, Meredith is afraid as she leaves the hospital and stops at McDonald’s following a birth. Later, she and Kate are followed in their car as they make their way home from Dr. Feingold’s office, though the motive of their pursuer never becomes clear. We also learn that Josh and Meredith first met when he came to her aid following a car crash, leaving Meredith with the overwhelming sensation that she’s “the lucky one” in their relationship (261). Bea hits Shelby with a car, though in this case, no hero comes to the rescue: Instead, Bea disposes of Shelby as quickly as possible. Later, when Meredith threatens to call the police, Bea drives her in her own car to a hotel, framing her death as a suicide.
Taken together, these scenes illustrate related concepts of flight, pursuit, fear, control, chance, and disaster, showing just how dangerous and unpredictable the suburban landscape can be.
Though construction workers are never named or shown speaking to Kate directly, their presence in Kate’s home makes her uncomfortable. To her, they embody an invasive version of the male gaze. On one occasion, the workers “stop and stare” when she comes inside, making her feel like a stranger in her own home (132). On another, she takes issue with the men using her and Bea’s bathroom, where they “leave the toilet seat up, our own towels tilted and wet” (267).
Kate’s apprehension also has racist and xenophobic overtones, as she becomes uncomfortable when the men speak a language she can’t follow. When the power goes out and Kate suspects an intruder, she considers the construction workers as possible suspects. Kate’s fear of the construction workers comes to nothing, and contrasts with her ignorance of Bea’s violence. Here, Kubica shows how loved ones, rather than strangers, can be the bigger threat.
Kubica shows how women are often denigrated during pregnancy and labor. We see how women’s bodies can be subjugated when people like Dr. Feingold lose sight of their personhood, viewing mothers as secondary to the children they give birth to. Shelby’s labor and delivery is another example of Freedom Versus Captivity. Though she is not captive in a physical sense like Carly or Delilah, she is captive to someone else’s care, where she is helpless.
By Mary Kubica