51 pages • 1 hour read
Nina SimonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Lana arrives at the land trust building and is told that the library door sticks frequently, implying that she was not locked in the room. She discovers most of the trust’s paperwork was destroyed in the fire. While Lana thinks that Diana could have caused the fire, she also does not think that starting a fire is Diana’s style. The woman working at the trust, Gaby, believes that Ricardo was seeing someone, and she tells Lana that he rode a bike with two panniers everywhere he went. Ricardo uncharacteristically called in sick the Thursday before he died, and Victor and Ricardo had a terrible argument before Ricardo took his panniers and left. That was the last time Gaby saw him. When Ricardo left on his bike, he headed toward Diana’s house. Lana realizes that she was wrong in thinking the deaths were about real estate. Instead, they are about love though she does not know what type. She thinks that Ricardo might have been misleading Diana and Victor about going along with their ideas while he was secretly planning with Hal.
From the news, Jack learns that the bike she saw at the Shack was Ricardo’s, and she tells Lana that there was only one pannier on the bike she saw. Beth learns that the workers in the mailroom sometimes allow guests in on Mondays even though they are not allowed.
Lana learns that Hal was definitely murdered, but before she can give more details, she is interrupted by the detectives who have gotten a warrant to search Paul’s property but do not know where he is. Lana does not believe Paul was involved, but Nicoletti is convinced he is. The detectives ask Lana if there is anyone they can talk to about Paul’s whereabouts, but Lana wants to talk to the man herself before she gives them a name. Later, she assures Jack that she does not believe Paul is guilty.
Jack researches Diana and learns that she was engaged to a duke in England who died in his sleep. Lana believes that Diana is responsible for his death. Lana plans to help Diana with a presentation she is going to make to Martin, and she wonders if Diana did not kill Martin because they are working together.
Lana calls Ramirez and tells her that she believes Diana is the culprit, and she asks the detective to go with her to the Rhoads’s dinner as her date. Ramirez declines because she has to focus on Paul, per Nicoletti’s orders. Meanwhile, Martin calls Beth and asks her to get Lana to stop her investigation; she has been working with Diana, and Martin believes they will implicate him. He then asks if she will come to the dinner party and tells her that she can bring Jack.
Lana sees Scotty at the docks and tells him that she needs to talk to Paul. She knows they have been growing marijuana plants undercover. They go inside, and Lana smells a skunky smell. When Scotty tells her that it is now legal to grow them, she reminds him that is only the case if they have a permit. She tells Paul that she knows who the murderer is, but in order to prove their guilt, she needs Paul’s help. Paul and Scotty explain that they are trying to create a hybrid strain of marijuana on their leased land, but they did not have a permit. After people started investigating after the murder, they dug up their plants and brought their operation here. She tells them that she thinks Diana killed Ricardo and that they were having an affair. Lana gets a voicemail from her daughter saying that she and Jack are going to dinner at the Rhoads’ house, and Lana thinks Diana set this up. She convinces Paul to come with her, and she does not believe they should contact the police at this point because they only care about Paul.
Beth and Jack arrive at the house, and Diana tells them that Lana is not there yet. Meanwhile, Paul takes out the Maglite he hid from the police and plans to use it as a weapon if necessary. In the kitchen, Beth sees a photo of a group of people after the replacement barn was built. She recognizes a woman from the photo Hal had hidden, and Martin tells her that the woman is Sofia, whose husband died in the barn fire. Finally, Lana arrives.
Martin tells the dinner party that according to the news, there is a warrant for Paul’s arrest. Lana goes outside to grab some pills from her car, and she sees the pickup truck she remembers from the day of the fire. She believes this is the proof she needs, and she texts Ramirez to meet her at the house. Then, in Martin’s car, she sees a black bag. Ramirez wants to know where Paul is, and Lana tells the detective that he will be at the house. Lana goes back in the house and sneaks upstairs. She finds a room with a twin bed, sees dirt, and knows that someone has been there recently. She finds some notes in Diana’s drawer and recognizes the handwriting as being the same as in the letter she previously found. She also sees a photo of Ricardo when he was young, and she realizes that the relationship between Diana and Ricardo was not a sexual one.
Jack goes out to the barn and looks around. She finds a catcher’s mitt that has both Martin and Ricardo’s name on it. Lana realizes that the murder centered around familial love. Hal and Ricardo got close over the years, and Martin felt left out. They realize that Martin could have killed Ricardo, gone to San Francisco for his alibi, and then could have come back to Elkhorn to dispose of the body. Martin and Diana come to the barn, and Martin blocks the exit. Lana tells them that she knows about Ricardo and Hal’s plans, and she tells Diana that Martin killed Ricardo at the ranch. She also tells them that the police are coming.
Lana tells Martin that she understands being unappreciated by family. Meanwhile, Diana confirms that Ricardo was staying at their house once a week. Ricardo meant a lot to her because he helped her heal after her fiancé’s death. She had wanted him to help build her wellness center, but they had a disagreement when she learned he was already working with Hal. She did not tell anyone because she knew that her fiancé’s death would make her a suspect. Lana directs her attention to Martin and talks about how it must have felt for him to know that Ricardo was in their house. Martin hits her, and she falls down.
Jack tries to go after Martin, but she gets injured. Martin is angry at Lana for bringing Ricardo back into their home. He believes he was protecting what belongs to Diana and himself by killing Ricardo. He then killed his father when he realized that he, too, was going to take away their inheritance. After finishing his speech, Martin reveals that he has a gun.
Martin starts pouring gasoline around the barn. He plans to tell people that it was the bird bombs that started the fire. He tells Diana that he has been hiding a secret for 30 years, but she says that she knows that he accidentally started the fire that killed their mother. Hal helped Martin cover his tracks, but he also told him that he would never forgive him. Martin flicks his lighter.
At that moment, Jack grabs the kayak and hits Martin, knocking the lighter and the gun out of his hands. Suddenly there is an explosion, and part of the barn catches fire. Jack loses consciousness.
Detective Ramirez comes into the barn and arrests Martin. The authorities arrive, and Ramirez is in charge of the scene.
Ramirez and Lana meet up, and Martin pleads guilty to almost all of the charges. Diana has decided to use the land to bring both her wellness spa and the plan Ricardo and Hal had devised to life. Lana gives Ramirez a more traditional outfit as a gift to celebrate Ramirez’s promotion, but Ramirez says she has to wear loud clothes in order to get people’s attention. Meanwhile, Lana’s tumors are decreasing in size. She can return home and go to work, but she is uncertain about what she wants to do.
Beth and Lana decide that it is best if Lana leaves so Jack can have her room back. Jack learns about an internship program that she might want to pursue with the harbormaster. Lana is looking to build her business in Elkhorn and is going to live in Beth’s garage, which Lana will start remodeling the next day.
Lana does not easily relate to her daughter, but she does relate to Diana, and this is because both Lana and Beth have difficulty empathizing with those who are different from them. From the beginning, Diana and Lana are shown to be similar in their desire to live a life of class and privilege. Because Lana understands Diana, she does not believe that she could have started the fire because she does not believe that a fire is Diana’s style. However, she still believes Diana could be responsible for the murders. Lana and Beth have conflicting values, so they rarely try to understand each other. This is largely why their relationship suffers. They see each other as being different and thus unrelatable. Lana is able to identify with Diana, and as a result, she can empathize with her and gain a better understanding of her motives and character. This demonstrates the importance and value of empathy and understanding in personal relationships.
The character of Paul is a red herring meant to throw the detectives, the amateur sleuths, and the reader off the track of the main culprit. This is a common tactic used in detective or crime fiction in order to build suspense and intrigue. He has no clear motive, except a weak one that only Nicoletti believes. Still, his actions are suspicious because he is trying to cover up his marijuana growing enterprise. These suspicious actions at first cause Lana to wonder whether he is the murderer, but she eventually decides that he is not. His character is important for building suspense because he poses the most danger to Jack. He is Jack’s employer, and as such, he has access to her. This makes Beth question whether Jack is safe going to work. While Paul is not involved in the murder at all, he remains crucial to the plot of the novel as he is used to add suspense as well as to throw the reader off the track of who the true culprit is. Finally, his character is used to demonstrate the closed-mindedness of Nicoletti as once the detective has made up his mind, he refuses to change it.
While Lana originally believed that property was the motive for murder, she realizes that love was, instead, the motive. This advances the primary theme in the novel of the importance of familial love and The Limits of Family Bonds. Lana has made property her life’s work as a real estate professional. Previously in the novel, she explained to Jack why property is so important: It can give people power, but it can also become a part of a person’s identity. This is something that Beth learned living in Elkhorn, and it is something that Jack can likely understand because the slough means so much to her.
As important as property is in the novel, love is shown to be even more important. After all, love is what causes Lana to give up her successful business to start again in Elkhorn. It is also what prompted Beth to take her mother in during her time of need even though the two did not have much of a relationship at the time. Love turned to jealousy is what caused the murders. Martin felt like he did not have access to his father’s love after he accidentally killed his mother in the fire, and when he saw that love being given to someone else, Ricardo, he could not bear it, and he killed both Hal and Ricardo. Love and familial relationships are shown to be so important in the novel that they can lead to either healing or destruction. Even when the main parties in the relationship want to deny its importance, they never are able to overcome the bonds that tie them to those they love.