79 pages • 2 hours read
Neil GaimanA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Content Warning: This section of the guide contains descriptions of suicidal ideation.
Islington, who is neither male nor female, offers Door and Richard some wine that was gifted to it by Door’s ancestors. Islington has had the wine for tens of thousands of years; the wine was made with a type of grape grown in the ancient and legendary city of Atlantis, of which Islington was the caretaker. It asks what Door and Richard want; Door asks who ordered her family’s murders and why, and Richard says he wants to return to his old life. Islington says it can give them both what they’re after if they can retrieve a key from the Black Friars. Islington gives Door a figurine made of obsidian―exactly like the one that the Marquis took from her father’s study―telling her that it will return Door to Islington after their journey. Islington returns them to the museum, hours after the party has ended, and they make their way back to London Below to meet up with Hunter. They are incredibly drunk from the wine, and when they pass out, Hunter carries their bodies to an unknown location.
The Marquis tells Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar that he wants to make a deal with them. He shows Mr. Croup the T’ang Dynasty ceramic figurine that Lear stole for him, which Mr. Croup wants because he collects them. Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar threaten to kill the Marquis and take it, but he brandishes a hammer and tells them to stay back, suggesting he will destroy the antique if they try. The Marquis and Mr. Croup agree that the figurine will be handed over after each man answers three questions; they also agree that the Marquis will get an hourlong head start after the transaction before Croup and Vandemar pursue him.
The Marquis asks who they’re working for; Mr. Croup says, “We are working for our employer, who wishes to remain nameless” (217). The Marquis then asks why they killed Door’s family; Mr. Croup evades the question again and says their employer ordered them to. When the Marquis asks his third question, which is why they didn’t kill Door when they could, Mr. Vandemar jumps in and says that they need her to open a door. Mr. Croup, angry that Mr. Vandemar let this information slip, asks the Marquis why he’s protecting Door. The Marquis answers that Lord Portico saved his life. The assassins ask why Door allows Richard to travel with her; the Marquis answers that it boils down to sentimentality. Mr. Vandemar takes the third question and asks the Marquis to guess the number he’s thinking of; the Marquis correctly guesses seven.
The Marquis gives Mr. Croup the figurine and leaves. Mr. Croup eats the statue, marveling at the destruction, and immediately sends Mr. Vandemar to follow the Marquis. They catch up to the Marquis within the hour and knock him out.
Hunter, Door, and Richard are all dreaming; Hunter is asleep standing up so she can be ready to defend Door. Hunter dreams about the Great Weasel, a creature she killed in Thailand, except in her dream, they dance. Door dreams about when her father taught her to open things. She fails to open a padlock, and when she gets frustrated, he tells her, “Remember […] the padlock wants to open. All you have to do is let it do what it wants” (225). In the dream, she asks her father who put away his journal, referring to the real-life situation of finding it in a cabinet after his death, but the dream fades before he answers. Richard, once again, dreams of the Beast, but before it can kill him, he wakes up because Hunter throws a bucket of water on him.
Both Door and Richard are both hungover, and Richard asks where they are. Hunter says they’re in the stables of someone she knows, and Door determines it belongs to a woman named Serpentine. Afraid, Door wants to leave before they’re discovered, but Serpentine enters right at that moment. She reveals that Hunter used to work for her and therefore Door and Richard will not be harmed. She offers them food, and as they eat, she calls Richard Door’s hero: “You learn to recognize the type. Something in the eyes, perhaps” (230). Serpentine tells Door that she thought Lord Portico’s plan to unite the Underside was foolish and she feels justified when Door reveals that he was murdered. After getting their fill, Hunter, Door, and Richard make their way to the Black Friars.
Old Bailey is telling jokes to his bird companions when the box the Marquis had given him begins beating like a heart and glowing. He understands immediately that the Marquis is in serious trouble.
While they travel to see the Black Friars, Hunter talks about beasts she has defeated and declares that she will kill the Great Beast of London or die trying. They walk into a thick, yellow fog, which Door explains is the echo of London fog―the result of severe air pollution from coal burning. Even though London Above hasn’t had it in about four decades, it still occurs in London Below. Door explains that there are time bubbles in London Below that hold onto things that happened in London Above years ago, like the fog.
At the abbey of the Black Friars, the Abbot awaits the trio’s arrival; he had dreamed they were on their way. They reach a bridge guarded by a Black Friar, who asks them to identify themselves. Richard states they want the key and tries to cross the bridge, but the friar knocks him back. Hunter engages the friar and the two fight. Hunter gets the friar to concede, and she, Door, and Richard are granted permission to cross the bridge. In the middle of the bridge, another friar presents them with a riddle, which Door solves. The Abbot comes forward and states that the third—meaning Richard—must now face the Ordeal of the Key. Hunter tries to take his place, but the Abbot refuses. Holding the three companions at crossbow, the friars force Richard to accompany the Abbot. Richard learns the ordeal is deadly―the friars keep a wall memorializing all who failed―but it is the only way to get the key Islington needs. As the unofficial first part of the Ordeal of the Key, the Abbot offers Richard a cup of tea, but Richard declines to drink it, preferring to get the ordeal over with. The Abbot leads Richard into a chamber and closes the door.
Door tells Hunter that if she’d known about the ordeal, she would have gone to find the Marquis first so that he could face it instead of Richard. Unbeknownst to her, the Marquis is being crucified by Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar.
Richard finds himself at Blackfriars Station and parks himself on a bench not long before a mother walks by with her daughter and says people like Richard are pathetic because they won’t just end their lives. He can’t remember why he’s at the station, and he feels deeply depressed. Richard’s friend Garry sits next to him, but when Richard tries to explain his appearance, Garry says that he’s not really there with Richard. Then, Garry turns into another Richard, who says that he’s all that’s left of the real Richard’s sanity and that the real Richard is sitting on a bench talking to himself in the middle of rush hour. He tells Richard to look closely at his surroundings because he’s “the closest [he’s] been in a week to reality” (253), and Richard suddenly becomes aware of dozens of people. He sees his reflection in a subway train; he looks like an erratic, unhoused version of himself. He covers his face, and when he looks up, he finds himself alone again until a woman’s hand clasps his.
It’s Jessica—but she says she’s really him, Richard. His other self—the one that originally appeared as Gary—is still there. Richard asks if this is part of the ordeal, and they tell him that he had a mental health crisis and has been wandering London for a couple of weeks. He returns to the version of the station that is bustling with people; someone knocks into him, and he falls onto the platform. He is lying in vomit and whimpering. The rush-hour travelers disappear, and the apparition of Gary is there again. Gary tells him he’s trying to get up the pluck to jump onto the tracks and end his life; he then tosses him a troll doll, which Richard fails to catch.
The travelers return. Getting kicked and stepped on, Richard crawls toward the edge of the platform where the troll now sits. An elderly woman kicks it off the platform, and then all the commuters vanish again. Richard makes it to the edge of the platform and sees a message on the opposite wall telling him to kill himself. Just as he’s about to give in, he reaches into his pocket and finds Anaesthesia’s quartz bead that he kept. He hears her voice, telling him to hold on. When the oncoming train approaches, Richard doesn’t jump in front of it. The doors open, and he sees that the car is filled with corpses of those who have died by suicide. Richard boards the train and is engulfed in darkness.
Back in the abbey, the door to the ordeal room opens. The Abbot assumes Richard is dead, but Richard stands and says he got through the ordeal and then asks for the cup of tea. The friars, shocked, give him the key. Richard rejoins Door and Hunter, and upon realizing that he has succeeded in getting the key, Door hugs him. Watching the trio leave, the Abbot says to himself, “We have lost the key […] God help us all” (262).
Islington dreams of the day when Atlantis sinks. After the angel wakes, it calls Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar, revealing it is their employer. Islington demands that they keep Door safe until she returns to Islington, but it says they’re free to kill the Marquis when Mr. Croup asks about it. Mr. Croup relays this to Mr. Vandemar after the call ends, and the latter suggests they get rid of the Marquis de Carabas’ body, as they had already killed him. Mr. Vandemar loads the body into a shopping cart, and as he rolls it along, Mr. Croup says they should be proudly displaying the remains of the Marquis, not just tossing him away. Regardless, they dump his body into the sewer.
Door, Hunter, and Richard leave the friars with the key. Hunter stops a young boy passing by and he tells them that the next floating market is that night, in Belfast. Soon after, a pale woman in black velvet emerges from the shadows to ask when the next market is; Richard recognizes her as someone he saw while wandering the market in Harrod’s. Door tells him that she’s a Velvet, a group of women who sleep all day and only emerge at night. As the trio make their way to the market, Richard wonders whether the Marquis will be there to meet them.
As the Marquis floats along—ultimately headed toward the Thames Estuary—some rats see him and one of them jumps onto his body to investigate. Another rat, one with black fur, goes to the Golden—a group of rats with golden fur—and they talk. The black rat then visits Old Bailey, appearing to tell him that the Marquis’s body was found. Old Bailey grabs the box the Marquis gave him and asks the rat where the market will be that night.
Back in the sewer, Dunnikin, the Chief of the Sewer Folk, spots a mobile phone and scoops it out of the water, adding it to a pile of refuse he hopes to sell at that night’s market. The Marquis’s body floats toward Dunnikin and his people, and they take his coat and all of the items in the pockets.
The meeting with Islington sets Door and her companions on the next stage of their quest, and although the angel is finally revealed as the novel’s ultimate antagonist, Richard and Door do not yet perceive The Threat of Treachery that surrounds their supernatural host. At this point in the narrative, they remain focused upon the task that the angel has set for them: retrieving the key from the Black Friars.
To get this key, the trio must complete a series of tests that represent the midpoint of the archetypal Hero’s Journey. Hunter defeats the friar at the bridge to get halfway across. Then, Door successfully answers the riddle to reach the far side of the bridge. That’s when she realizes that she and Hunter have unwittingly condemned Richard to the most dangerous part of the test: the ordeal. This is truly a test of Richard’s inner strength, and he comes to understand The Transformative Nature of Sacrifice when the ordeal tries to unmake his very essence by convincing him that nothing he’s experienced in London Below is real and that he has experienced a mental health crisis and is wandering the streets. Wavering back and forth between two realities—one in which he is alone with figments of his imagination and another where he is among a crowd of Upsiders waiting for a subway train—Richard must determine what is real. He is on the verge of dying by suicide, as his hallucinations nearly convince him that this is the right thing to do. However, touching the bead from Anaesthesia’s necklace brings him some much-needed clarity by reminding him of her sacrifice. This thought inspires him to persevere, and he successfully completes the ordeal.
In keeping with the theme of self-sacrifice, the Marquis de Carabas gives his life to find out information from Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar. This event clears the Marquis of any suspicion of treason, creating a level of dramatic irony given that no one else in the story, least of all Richard, knows just how much the Marquis has sacrificed for Door’s benefit.
Islington’s memories of the sinking Atlantis show his former failure to care for a flourishing city. Whatever remorse the angel feels is offset by the revelation that it hired Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar. This betrayal might be the one that the men mentioned to Richard and Door, and it’s a huge turning point in the story, especially because Lord Portico’s final journal entry told Door to trust Islington. This section brings into play the theme of betrayal. It isn’t yet stated why Islington has done any of this, but readers can surmise that he needs a door opened, and Door is the only one who can do it.
By Neil Gaiman