62 pages • 2 hours read
Roméo DallaireA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Dallaire fell in love with Rwanda as soon as he arrived. He met with the Rwandan diplomat to the UN, Jean-Damascène Bizimana, another ambassador Anatese Gasada, and the Rwandan ambassador to Uganda. Gasada was an opponent of Habyarimana’s regime and backed the transition to a full democracy. Dallaire also met with Prime Minister Agathe Uwilingiyimana, nicknamed “Madame Agathe,” who was a political moderate in support of the Arusha Accords. Even at that time, there were “ominous rumblings of the extremist elements and [. . .] the presence of militias, which had inserted themselves into the youth wings of the various political parties, even the moderate ones” (59-60).
Dallaire was taken to see Paul Kagame, a Tutsi leader of the RPF, at a refugee camp. Other RPF leaders he encountered were Alexis Kanyarengwe, a Hutu who led the RPF, and Pasteur Bizimungu. The RPF was “unanimous in its support for Arusha” (66). While at the camp, Dallaire became “personally dedicated […] to bringing a UN peacekeeping mission to Rwanda” (64).
Next, Dallaire met the RGF, led by Major General Déogratias Nsabimana. Some of the RGF leaders wanted the peace to work out, but others still hated the RPF. Dallaire noticed that the rank and file of the RGF lived in poor conditions while the officers were trained by French and Belgian military advisers. The RGF also used children as servants and Dallaire suggests they may have been sexually exploited.
In his report to the UN, Dallaire recommended making UNAMIR a chapter-six peacekeeping mission, which would involve a combination of armed troops and unarmed observers who could only use weapons in self-defense. This was in contrast to a chapter-seven mission, which would involve a direct military intervention, but “there were no strategic national or international interests and no major threat to international peace and security” (71). At that time, chapter-seven had only been used in Korea during the Korean War of the 1940s, during the Gulf War in Iraq, and in Somalia. Dallaire pushed to extend the rules of engagement to include “the use of deadly force to prevent ‘crimes against humanity’” (72).
Dallaire found his fluency in both French and English to be useful since the RPF delegation, made up largely of refugees who had lived in English-speaking Uganda, was mostly Anglophone, while the Rwandan government was entirely French-speaking. His biggest hurdle was talking about demilitarization and the creation of a new national army, but a lack of information was once again a problem, since the UN did not “supply [him] with information on how other missions dealt with the problem” (74). He also realized that the mission needed more than the $50 million previously estimated in the budget.
Dallaire finally encountered President Habyarimana, whose stance worried Dallaire because “he had not publicly embraced the mission” (77). Although Dallaire called the United Nations Assistance Mission for Rwanda (UNAMIR) “both possible and essential” (77), he began to feel disillusioned by the stark contrast between the luxurious lives of the UN bureaucrats, who seemed “inured to the poverty around them” (78).
Dallaire was disappointed when he found that the “process of mission approval and troop deployment” (80) in Rwanda would take three months. Although Dallaire was able to get a small force of 2,600 soldiers with armored vehicles, he struggled to get them ammunition and supplies, a problem that would never resolve during his time in Rwanda. The United States, a powerful voice on the UN’s Security Council, “never took Rwanda or me seriously; their position continued to be that the job could be done with much fewer personnel” (84). It was difficult to rally support for Rwanda among the member nations of the UN, including Dallaire’s home country, Canada because, “Rwanda was on nobody’s radar as a place of strategic interest. It had no natural resources and no geographical significance” (89). Only Belgium, Rwanda’s former colonizer state, showed a willingness to get closely involved. Dallaire found an ally in Dr. Abdul Hamid Kabia, a diplomat from Sierra Leone and the political officer of the Rwanda mission.
The UN’s plan for Rwanda was laid out in phases. Phase One involved the withdrawal of French military forces that were seen as the RGF’s allies, turning the capital city of Kigali into a weapons-free zone. The United Nations would begin monitoring the demilitarized zone for outbreaks of violence. Phase Two would see a 2,548-member force occupy the demilitarized zone while the RPF and the RGF demobilized, and Phase Three would involve “the actual demobilization and reintegration process and would last ten months” (88). The fourth (and final) phase would introduce democratic elections. The UN assumed the process would be rapid and straightforward: “In UN terms, the mission was to be small, cheap, short and sweet” (89). Following a trip to speak with officials in Uganda about the mission, Dallaire felt as if the world governments were much better informed about political developments in Rwanda than he was. Dallaire claims that “[n]ot one country was willing to provide the UN or even me personally with accurate and up-to-date information” (90).
Dallaire set up headquarters at the Hôtel des Mille Collines in Kigali, receiving vehicles and local drivers. Nonetheless, supplies remained an issue for Dallaire, and he clashed frequently with the Chief Administration Officer, Per Hallqvist.
Another problem was RTLM, the “hardline radio station” that promoted anti-Tutsi “racist hype” (101). Dallaire had to handle diplomatic problems and promote UNAMIR’s activities to the Rwandan public while “forced to fight a petty internal war over vehicles and office supplies” (107). In order to spread awareness of the mission, Dallaire conducted a UN flag-raising ceremony at the village of Kinihira, where most of the peace negotiations were taking place. President Habyarimana and members of his political party (MRND), did not attend. Dallaire saw their absence as a “deliberate slight to UNAMIR” (104). However, when UNAMIR’s headquarters were opened at Amahoro Stadium in Kigali, President Habyarimana gave a speech promoting UNAMIR.
Ominous signs remained. In neighboring Burundi, the democratic government, led by a Hutu, was overthrown by Tutsi military officers. The coup had an immediate negative impact on Rwanda: “Kigali was thick with rumours and suspicion, and the local media was full of hysterical talk of Tutsi hegemony” (98). Meanwhile, the burgomaster (mayor) of the town of Nkumba reported that 21 men, women, and children were killed and two people were kidnapped, all associated with the MRND. The Rwandan media blamed the RPF. After the government neglected to investigate, UNAMIR attempted to probe the massacre without success. UNAMIR’s “failure to find the perpetrators of the November 17 to 18 massacre became ‘proof’ for the hard-liners that UNAMIR was biased against the regime and was a closet RPF supporter” (112). Another massacre blamed on the RPF took place in a village in northwestern Rwanda.
UNAMIR was reinforced by Belgian soldiers who had racist attitudes toward the Rwandans, which Dallaire tried to quell with a speech. Jean-Jacques Booh-Booh, a diplomat from Cameroon who was appointed the head of UNAMIR, “turned out to be a proper gentleman who kept diplomatic working hours” (118)—meaning he worked few hours, refused to work on weekends, and was not involved in dealing with the massacres. When Dallaire discovered that the November 17/18 massacre was carried out by RGF commandos, Booh-Booh refused to authorize an operation since it “might further jeopardize the political process” (122).
Further negotiations were to take place at Kinihira on December 10, but they did not go far. The situation grew increasingly tense, as “there was an increasingly violent tone to political discourse, fed by the broadcasts of RTLM” (123). Meanwhile, Dallaire was busy trying to impose the KWSA (Kigali Weapons Secure Area) agreement, which proved difficult to enforce since the RGF continued moving weapons just outside the KWSA. Dallaire also worked on Operation Clean Corridor, which would provide a secure route for RPF representatives to enter Kigali. Dallaire disagreed with the decision to hold negotiations for the new government, called the Broad-Based Transitional Government (BBTG) at the National Council for Development (CND) where the National Assembly of Rwanda met, since it would look like the RDF was occupying the center of Rwandan politics. Despite these obstacles, Dallaire was pleased with the mission’s progress.
These chapters cover the early months of UNAMIR before the genocide began. From his perspective after the events have taken place, Dallaire seeks to understand how a political situation that seemed to be going well—albeit with some problems and tensions—ended in such catastrophe: “I felt that I had worked very hard and had come up with a mission plan that could work […] I did not understand that I had just met men in Rwanda who would become génocidaires” (79). Dallaire does not seek to obscure the early warning signs of failure in order to build suspense for the reader; instead, he uses the benefit of hindsight to provide a glimpse into how the Causes of Genocide may be apparent even in times of relative political calm. This confessional narrative strategy emphasizes Dallaire’s objective to criticize the geopolitical status quo and call for greater moral accountability.
Even at the early stages on his mission, Dallaire was hindered by four factors that continued to torment him over the course of the UNAMIR mission. The first involved Bureaucracy and Political Needs versus Humanitarian Intervention, a perpetual lack of resources, supplies, manpower, and time. As he notes at the beginning of UNAMIR, “In twelve days, my small eighteen-member team and I had to assess the political, humanitarian, administrative and military aspects of a potential UN peacekeeping mission” (58). The same basic logistical issues would remain even as UNAMIR expanded and evolved. The second factor was constant disagreements with his superiors or with the bureaucratic and political side of UNAMIR, whether it was Per Hallqvist, Jacques-Roger Booh-Booh, or Kofi Annan. The third factor was a lack of information on the full political situation in Rwanda; neither the political establishment in Rwanda nor the governments of the UN member states kept him adequately informed. Finally, there was the overall reluctance of the UN member states to commit troops and resources to UNAMIR. Dallaire suspects that their reluctance not only contributed to UNAMIR’s ongoing resource and manpower problems, but was also a major reason the genocide was carried out. The Rwandan political and military leaders who would become génocidaires “had judged that the West was too obsessed with the former Yugoslavia and with its peace-dividend reductions of its military forces to get overly involved in central Africa” (79). Dallaire’s cynicism is an indictment of nations that prioritize economic and militaristic concerns over humanitarian crises.
African History
View Collection
Canadian Literature
View Collection
Colonialism & Postcolonialism
View Collection
Globalization
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
War
View Collection