52 pages • 1 hour read
Kody KeplingerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section includes discussion of school shootings, death by gun violence, trauma, mental and emotional health concerns, substance use disorder, and grief.
A cross necklace is typically a symbol of the Christian faith, but in That’s Not What Happened, it also symbolizes the unfair and biased judgments at the heart of Lee’s conflict. Though most peers, community members, and the wider public believe that the cross necklace in Sarah’s school picture was the one found in the bathroom, Lee knows the truth: Sarah’s school picture cross was a necklace she did not care about and only wore because her grandmother gave it to her. The necklace in the bathroom was not Sarah’s at all—but the strength of the false narrative spread first by Ashley, then others, connects that cross necklace to Sarah so inextricably that it is given to her parents to be buried with Sarah’s body.
Kellie eventually confirms what Lee suspects: The cross necklace in the bathroom was Kellie’s, but no one believed her; she attended a distant church, but since no one in their small town saw her attend, they assumed she did not attend any church, anywhere. The contrasting stereotypes that people believed based on assumptions about Sarah and Kellie led to impactful false narratives. The cross necklaces serve as symbols that help to support the theme of The Role of Stereotyping in Shaping Narrative.
As part of her truth-telling mission, Lee shares information about each victim through written portraits. These portraits appear as a recurring motif in the novel. Lee’s goal is to help others see each victim as an individual with traits and characteristics; in this way, they might be remembered for more than their label as a victim of a tragic shooting. Lee also wants to elevate the importance of each victim compared to Sarah, whose name was mentioned the most in the aftermath thanks to the false narrative surrounding her death: “There was so much coverage about Sarah, but the other people who died were pretty much forgotten within a few weeks. They quickly became the unnamed dead, just a part of the ‘nine killed’” (64). For these reasons, the portraits symbolize individuality and each person’s importance in the bigger picture.
To accomplish these goals, Lee turns to other survivors for help; the survivor who knows the victim best authors the portrait. In this way, Lee frames the portrait through a particular lens or perspective of intimacy, with sometimes surprising results. Characteristic quirks like Jared’s preference for role-playing games and startling traits like Aiden’s quick gravitation to other girls upon breaking up with Brenna are noted, showing Lee and eventually readers that one’s perspective paints a particular version of truth. In this way, the portraits connect to and help develop the theme of The Complexities of Truth and Perspective.
The motif of guilt in the novel ebbs and flows between the recent events, the flashbacks, and the survivor letters, but it is always present. Lee caps several chapters with statements or implications that she is at fault, claiming responsibility for events like Kellie’s departure and the future impact of Sarah’s biography. Guilt drives Lee’s choice to tell the truth about Sarah. Ashley guilted Sarah for skipping youth group and lying about it to her parents, then felt guilt when Sarah dies. Eden feels guilty over her inability to get closer to Rosi before Rosi died. Miles’s guilt stems from a false narrative that upholds him as a hero who saved Ashley intentionally. This consistent undercurrent of guilt helps to support the theme of The Impact of Trauma on Individual Identity; characters adopt their guilt like they might a trait or skill. Guilt becomes a part of their identity and a character feature that prompts actions and decisions.
Lee requests Kellie’s contribution to the compilation because she wants to make amends; she hopes this promotion of the truth will alleviate her guilt. Ironically, Kellie initially refuses to contribute a letter but tries to absolve Lee’s guilt anyway, telling her that the “Sarah story” grew quickly out of Lee’s or Kellie’s control. The novel’s emphasis on personal, first-person letters conveys the message that one can alleviate guilt by telling the truth and reestablishing ownership of narratives.
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Education
View Collection
Forgiveness
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
LGBTQ Literature
View Collection
Mental Illness
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection