61 pages • 2 hours read
Tobias SmollettA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Matthew praises Edinburgh, speaking highly of the city, its inhabitants, and its culture. However, he is concerned about Lydia, whose “color fades, her appetite fails, and her spirits flag” (235). He has decided that she might fare better in the country. A friend has offered to let the family use his country house near Glasgow, so Matthew plans to leave Edinburgh soon.
Jeremy writes from the Scottish Highlands, where he and his family are staying at a country estate on the shores of Lough-Lomond. It has been 10 days since they left Edinburgh, and both Jeremy and Matthew continue to enjoy Scotland. Jeremy praises Scottish culture while also noting that many aspects of it are oppressed by English authorities. He praises both the food and the natural beauty of the area. It is now early September, and Jeremy notes that the group plans to travel through more of Scotland but to return to England before too long, since there “Boreas is not quite so biting as he begins already to be on the tops of these northern hills” (244).
Matthew writes to give his impression of the Highlands; he is generally impressed by the picturesque scenery that surrounds him, and he observes with pleasure that “every thing here is romantic beyond imagination” (248). Matthew includes a copy of “a little ode to this river, by Dr. Smollett, who was born on the banks of it” (249).
Matthew writes again, continuing to praise Scotland and the country estate where he is staying. He is enjoying learning about Scottish culture and history, and his health is improving. Although they will soon begin their journey home, Matthew observes that, “I have received so much advantage and satisfaction from this tour” (257) and that he would like to plan more travels in the future.
Lydia writes to her friend, explaining that while she has enjoyed the travels in Scotland, she continues to be preoccupied by her feelings for Wilson: “I never admitted but one idea of love, and that has taken such root in my heart, as to be equally proof against all the pulls of discretion” (258). Lydia describes her encounter with Wilson at the ball at Edinburgh: She recognized him even though he was in disguise, and she became very distressed. No one else other than her brother Jeremy knows about her encounter with Wilson, and Jeremy’s disgust with Wilson’s behavior has prompted her to reflect. Lydia also writes that she is often embarrassed by both Tabitha and Winifred’s efforts to ensnare men; she has more sympathy for Winifred, who does not have Tabitha’s class advantages, but she finds that both women behave in inappropriate ways.
Winifred believes that the Scottish woods and countryside are home to supernatural beings, and she writes to describe her fears: “[T]his is the land of congyration [conjuration]” (261).
Jeremy writes to his friend from the city of Carlisle in northern England; the family has now begun their journey home, and made their way out of Scotland and back over the English border. Jeremy focuses on two episodes that have occurred during this most recent journey. First, near the town of Clydesdale, the travelers witnessed a heartwarming reunion between a man named Mr. Brown and his estranged son, William. William left his hometown years earlier and was able to make a good income working as a captain in the East Indies. He is now able to financially support his entire family and provide for his parents and siblings.
In the second episode, near Carlisle, the group came across a drowned horse, which they realized was Lismahago’s; this discovery led them to surmise that “our friend the lieutenant had shared the fate of his horse” (266). However, a short time later, they encountered Lismahago alive and well. Lismahago explained that he did not receive the warm welcome he had expected in Scotland and is now making his way to London so that he can sail from there to America and start a new life for himself. Matthew deduces that Lismahago is struggling with his finances, and he suggests that Lismahago accompany the group back to Brambleton Hall and stay with them. Lismahago is going to travel with the group for some time while considering this idea. Jeremy predicts that Lismahago is going to end up marrying Tabitha.
Matthew writes about the final stretch of the journey in Scotland, including the meeting with Lismahago in Carlisle. He has observed that Lismahago and Tabitha seem to be pursuing a romantic relationship, and he “intends to encourage this correspondence, and shall be glad to see them united” (273). Matthew wants to be able to see Lismahago regularly, but thinks it would be difficult to live with him full time; if Lismahago and Tabitha get married, they will move into a home of their own, and Matthew won’t have to tolerate the discomfort of living with them.
Tabitha writes to her housekeeper, explaining that she expects to be home by early October and giving instructions on maintaining the house and farm. She also observes that Humphry has been a good influence on Winifred, and that she hopes he will also encourage good behavior in other household servants.
Matthew describes how he and Lismahago have returned to their old habit of having debates, and have argued about the political and cultural relationship between Scotland and England. Lismahago has also asked how Matthew would feel about his marrying Tabitha, and Matthew has been supportive. He predicts that Lismahago and Tabitha will marry shortly after the return to Brambleton Hall.
Jeremy describes a recent conflict between Matthew and Lismahago. Jeremy and Matthew had dinner with a distant relative named Lord Oxington. During the visit, Oxington offended Matthew, and Matthew decided to challenge the man to a duel. He sent Lismahago to deliver the challenge to Oxington; however, Oxington assumed Lismahago was a servant, and treated him with disdain. Lismahago was offended and embarrassed, and blamed Matthew for this embarrassing incident. Lismahago and Matthew almost ended up fighting in a duel themselves, but Tabitha intervened. The two men explain the mistake to Oxington, who apologizes and blames one of his own servants for the error.
As the Bramble-Melford family moves into the Highlands, they continue to express intense appreciation for Scottish culture and geography. The trip from densely populated Edinburgh into the Highlands also highlights The Contrast Between Urban and Rural. Matthew is even more delighted with his time in the countryside than he was in Edinburgh, rhapsodizing “this country would be a perfect paradise, if it was not, like Wales, cursed with a weeping climate” (250). The mild and poetically phrased complaint of a rainy (“weeping”) climate actually serves to allow for a parallel between Wales and Scotland, which hints at why Matthew may find this region particularly to his liking.
While the Bramble family’s Welsh identity is not strongly emphasized throughout the novel, it likely does contribute to some of the unease Matthew has felt while travelling, especially in larger towns and cities. Compared with London, Wales was less industrialized, more rugged, and was often praised for its natural beauty. The pairing of Scotland and Wales, and Matthew’s high regard for both, develops the text’s pastoral inclinations. Matthew is continually noticing The Contrast Between Urban and Rural, and in his mind, this contrast always shows the superiority of the rural. There is an irony in this attitude: Matthew seems most satisfied when he encounters landscapes, people, and cultural practices that resemble the home he has voluntarily left behind.
In order to celebrate this region of Scotland, Smollett also introduces metafictional elements. He situates the country house where the travelers stay in the locale where he was born, and directly references “a little ode to this river [the river Leven], by Dr. Smollett, who was born on the banks of it, within two miles of the place where I am now writing” (249). As an established and well-known author, Smollett can capitalize on his reputation to make the area he is describing even more alluring, and his genuine ties to the area also make him more credible when he praises and celebrates it. Smollett even inserts a short poem, entitled “Ode to Leven-Water” into the text, and openly attributes the authorship to himself, comingling reality and fiction.
The insertion of other genres (typically lyric poetry) into works of prose fiction was somewhat common in the 18th century. As an emerging genre, novels were viewed somewhat dubiously and typically perceived as more “low-brow” than poetry. Inserting poems could therefore add credibility and literary interest; it also allowed working writers to display their skills in multiple genres simultaneously. Smollett also intentionally deploys poetry to celebrate a scene of natural beauty, implying that prose is unequal to the task: “[T]here is an idea of truth in an agreeable landscape taken from nature, which pleases me more than the gayest fiction which the most luxuriant fancy can display” (249). Especially in the decades to follow, English Romantic poets such as William Wordsworth, John Keats, and Percy Bysshe Shelley would often use poetry to celebrate the beauties of the natural world; by aligning poetry with the world of nature and rural spaces, and fiction with something contrived and constructed (and thus implicitly aligned with urban spaces), Smollett also draws a literary parallel to The Contrast Between Urban and Rural.
During the family’s journey out of Scotland and back into England, they encounter Lismahago again, and this reunion develops the theme of Virtue and Integrity Amid the Lower Classes. Lismahago has fallen on hard times, and is “more meagre and grim than before” (266); as a Scottish man who has loyally served Great Britain but is now struggling to sustain himself, his plight serves to criticize England’s treatment of Scotland and its people. Matthew further displays his kind and generous nature by becoming “warmly interested on the side of compassion” (267), showing that he does not view financial and social status as an indication of moral worth. Matthew’s willingness to symbolically “adopt” Lismahago into his family reflects a fluid and open model of family: He has taken in his sister’s orphaned children (Jeremy and Lydia) and he will later also claim Humphry as a member of the family when their connection is uncovered. The idea that individuals who are struggling can still be worthy of a good life is reinforced by Matthew’s attempts to elevate and protect those whom he deems worthy, and implies a meritocratic model wherein integrity is rewarded, regardless of one’s social origins.
By Tobias Smollett