logo

40 pages 1 hour read

Andrzej Sapkowski

The Last Wish

Fiction | Short Story Collection | Adult | Published in 1993

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 7-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 7 Summary: “Chapter Four: The Voice of Reason”

Geralt tells Iola his story. He almost religiously believes in the sword. He is from Kaer Morhen, where now no one but his father Vesemir lives. He went through intense witcher training to protect the innocent from monsters.

He met his first “monster” on the road, when he encountered a group of highway robbers attempting to rape a small girl. Instead of being grateful for Geralt’s intervention, the girl’s father fled with the attackers, and the girl refused to allow Geralt to come near her.

Since that time, tries to listen to “the voice of reason” (133) and rarely interferes in regular affairs. However, he has regrets. One is Yennefer, whom he is loathe to discuss.

Chapter 8 Summary: “A Question of Price”

In Cintra, Geralt is dressing up for a banquet given by Queen Calanthe in honor of Princess Pavetta’s 15th birthday. The queen has hired Geralt, who will pose as the nobleman Ravis of Fourhorn. Geralt cannot coax the reason for his hire out of the castellan.

At the banquet, the queen is curt toward Geralt. He wonders whether she wants to hire him to murder someone, but she says this would be silly—he is too expensive to hire for such a simple task. Instead, she needs his help to ensure the princess’s marriage alliance with a nobleman from Skellige. The queen could command Geralt to carry out the task—in that case, she will spell out what he has to do and the punishment for disobedience would be severe. Alternatively, Geralt can choose to freely accept without knowing the details—this way, he can set his own price.

At that moment, Geralt notices Mousesack, a druid from Skellige, looking at him while forming runes into a question on the table out of breadcrumbs. Geralt nods quickly, and Mousesack brushes the crumbs away.

The princess arrives. The queen bemoans the alliance, but it is necessary. Geralt accepts her offer; the queen moves off to mingle with other guests.

Much later in the evening, a figure covered in heavy armor arrives, announcing himself as Urcheon of Erlenwald. The queen invites him to join their festivities, but he declines. The queen bemoans his lack of respect and demands he remove his helmet, but he must leave it on until midnight due to his knight order’s vows.

15 years ago, Urcheon rescued Calanthe’s husband, King Roegner. When the king offered Urcheon a reward, Urcheon “asked him to promise me whatever he had left at home without knowing or expecting it”; this had turned out to be the princess, as the king had not been aware that Calanthe had been pregnant (156). Now, Urcheon has come to collect the promised reward—the princess’s hand in marriage.

The banquet turns into an uproar, and Geralt’s witcher medallion, which grows active around magic, has been spinning—both he and Mousesack can sense something, though they are not sure what. The princess’s eyes dart between Mousesack and Geralt, while Mousesack mutters incantations.

Calanthe admits that Urcheon speaks the truth. She will convene a council the next day to determine whether the king’s promise still applies. Geralt exclaims that a council might not be necessary. Why would someone want an oath that “creates a powerful, indissoluble tie of destiny between the person demanding the oath and its object” (162)? He argues that the so-called Law of Surprise is only valid if the child consents. Urcheon questions Geralt’s expertise, but Mousesack explains that Geralt knows the law because it had once applied to him, leading to his becoming a witcher.

Calanthe confirms that Geralt is a witcher; as midnight has passed, she demands that Urcheon remove his helmet. He does, revealing that he is a humanoid monster. Calanthe believes she has won, as she is sure the princess won’t consent. However, shocking everyone, Pavetta does. Urcheon insists on leaving immediately, but the banquet descends into chaos, with everyone climbing over themselves to get at Urcheon. Geralt leaps to his defense, fighting off guards and suitors alike.

Pavetta is in increasing anguish, and the magic in the room grows more chaotic. The room explodes, with chairs, tables, and people flying everywhere. Mousesack and Geralt work together to block the princess’s powers. They succeed, and the princess collapses to the floor.

The druid reveals that Pavetta can use the Force, which had skipped a generation, because she is not a virgin. Urcheon reverts to human form—the castle clock rang early and it’s only midnight now.

In the queen’s chambers, Urcheon, or Duny reveals that he has been cursed since birth to only be human from midnight until dawn. He and the princess have been seeing one another for a year. Calanthe is perfectly capable of blocking their marriage, but she won’t. Instead, she will take Eist Tuirseach of Skellige as her husband—they, too, are secretly in love.

When dawn arrives and Duny remains human, they realize the curse has been lifted. Duny insists he owes a debt to Geralt for saving his life, so Geralt asks of Duny and Pavetta what Duny had asked of the king, the gift of something he has but does not know about—in other words, Pavetta’s unborn child. Geralt explains that witchers must be born under the shadow of destiny, which is why there are so few of them; he will return in six years to see if destiny has been kind to him. 

Chapters 7-8 Analysis

“The Voice of Reason” further interrogates the monster/human dichotomy in the world of the Witcher. Ironically, the first monster Geralt meets after his training is not supernatural, but human. The encounter encapsulates a running theme throughout the collection: Geralt’s services are necessary for people who cannot get rid of monsters on their own; however, his powers set him apart, so ordinary people will never accept him. Here, in return for his services, the girl’s father flees, and the girl is terrified of the man who saved her life.

“A Question of Price” is a counterpart to “The Lesser Evil”—both ask how we respond to unsavory situations, where we draw our limits, and why. “Lesser” did this by placing Geralt between two powerful, malevolent forces. The more lighthearted “Question” asks what our principles are worth. The queen doesn’t have many principles. Her cynical pragmatism makes her an interesting foil for Geralt: Geralt believes himself to be pure in his principles, but the tale suggests that Geralt has a price and that some things are important enough to him to bend his rules. We never learn why Geralt accepts the queen’s vague job offer—all we can gather is that he had a sense that destiny was involved, which is the only way for Geralt to quasi-father a witcher child.

The theme of the monstrous takes on a different shading here, as this story of a human-monster hybrid depends heavily on destiny and fate. Unlike other cursed humans, Urcheon doesn’t know why his fate is to be hedgehog by day and a human by night. Like a witcher, he does not choose his own path, but instead follows a destiny ordained by the Law of Surprise, which has made him and Geralt something other than human. Once Duny’s curse lifts, Geralt begins the cycle of destiny anew by requesting Duny and Pavetta’s child. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text