logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Douglas Brunt

The Mysterious Case of Rudolf Diesel: Genius, Power, and Deception on the Eve of World War I

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Militarism and Industrial Innovation

Brunt makes the connection between technological breakthroughs and military aims clear from the beginning of this book, stressing that many inventions were co-opted for wartime use in spite of their creators’ hopes: “Throughout history, the world has often adopted technological advances in ways the inventor never imagined, and certainly never intended [...] the unintended consequences of an inventor’s brainchild could wreak havoc and terror” (2) as nations used them for war.

The twin forces of nationalism and militarism defined Diesel’s world. When he was a child, Diesel and his family had to flee Germany for France, and then France for England, as European nations fought each other over territory and power. As he was developing his engine, Diesel was caught in the complex diplomatic dance of Britain, France, Germany, Russia, and Austria-Hungary jockeying for position via treaties and agreements that threatened the others.

Concerns about national security derailed Diesel’s dreams for his engine to be a tool for international cooperation and to become accessible and efficient for the working class. Although the licensing agreements he signed with manufacturers across the globe mandated they participate in a shared global knowledge base for engineers to pool their breakthroughs and improvements, “the sharing of new developments was tempered by the nationalism of the age” (122). The diesel engine’s international debut allowed governments to seize its military potential: Britain’s Lord Kelvin “was early to recognize an aspect of the engine that others would soon see as a key military differentiator: the ‘cold start” (112). In Germany, the Kaiser and Admiral Alfred von Tirpitz also immediately saw that the diesel engine could be key to their goal of rivaling the British navy. Britain and Germany used the engines to build up their militaries, applying the technology to battleships, tanks, and other instruments of war, so nationalist pressures made all diesel engine innovations into state secrets, ending Diesel’s idealistic vision and becoming a major turning point in the diesel engine’s history.

As soon as the engine was inextricably linked to military uses, some of its potential was stifled. One of the most exciting features of Diesel’s innovation was the ability to use many different fuel sources; however, each country adapted its version of the engine to suit the fuel it could access best. The environmentally friendly possibilities Diesel promoted were ignored.

Eventually, Diesel himself became as valuable as the technology he had developed. Despite its international manufacture, Diesel was still the leading expert on the complexities and applications of his engine. Brunt imagines that this meant that Britain and Germany did their best to ensure Diesel’s continued efforts for their side: “not only did the Kaiser need to enhance his nation’s expertise with Diesel technology, but it was equally important that Great Britain not enhance its own” (254). This undergirds Brunt’s theory that rather than dying on the SS Dresden, Diesel defected and was smuggled to Canada to continue his work for the Allied nations.

Connecting Art, Science, and Progress

Brunt explores how art and science impact progress by tracing how Diesel’s life was affected by exposure to the cultural products of his time. Brunt argues that the arts and sciences are both important catalysts of progress.

Brunt portrays Diesel as a child interested in math, science, and the arts: Not only did he “disassemble and analyze toys” (10), but he also loved visiting the museums of both Paris and London when his family lived in those cities. Diesel’s interdisciplinary approach, that of “a gifted but untrained mind for engineering, and who also loved the arts” (26), gave him an unusually broad worldview. In Paris, he was as fascinated by the gaslight that made Parisian streets safer to traverse as by the diagrams of inventions, patents, and notes from engineers and scientists on display in exhibitions such as the World’s Fair. In London, he witnessed the horrors of workhouses and factories, realizing that he could apply a newfound interest in social theory to engineering and becoming inspired to work on an invention that could positively change the world.

The World’s Fair, an annual event that brought together the newest innovations in all sectors, including the arts, sciences, design, and industry, was particularly important throughout Diesel’s life. As a boy, Diesel marveled at the seemingly endless rows of exhibitors. As an adult, he became an exhibitor, sharing his invention with the world as the work of others had inspired him. Presenting the World’s Fair as the pinnacle of human progress at the time, Brunt centers its recurrence in Diesel’s life: “The fair was a landmark occasion for the Diesel engine under the brightest spotlight of the international stage and the engine performance was remarkable [...] Diesel was delivering on his promise” (130-31). Readers understand the revolutionary nature of the diesel engine, when it was awarded top honors at the World’s Fair.

Brunt emphasizes the importance of Diesel’s Renaissance-man background, making it clear that Diesel’s multiplicity of passions made it possible for him to conceive of his engine. Excited about Nicolaus Otto’s steam-powered combustion engine, “the naive and optimistic youth who filled his time drawing contraptions he’d seen in exhibits, or more fantastical ones from his imagination determined in that moment that he could create a better machine” (26). According to Brunt, Diesel pushed the envelope of what was possible because of scientific and artistic influences. He made intellectual connections that may not have been as apparent to engineers with a less well-rounded background.

Influence of Wealth on Industrialization

Industrialization is inherently tied to economic factors and incentives. Throughout the book, Brunt argues that in capitalist economic systems, powerful business interests determine how and why industrialization progresses by delving into Rudolf Diesel’s licensing deals and Rockefeller’s business practices.

Diesel believed his engine’s compact, efficient, and economical design would help the working and artisan classes keep up with large factories and firms by being able to access the power of the steam engine. However, his licenses for manufacturing rights went solely to big businesses, whose large-scale commercial interests merited the hefty investment that the licensing fees represented. As wealthy business interests monopolized the manufacturing of the diesel engine, the more influence they had over its future uses and development. At the same time, increasingly industrialized factories devalued manual labor, undermining the working class that Diesel had initially set out to help. Brunt makes it clear that Diesel understood the implications of selling the manufacturing rights only to industrialists like Busch or Nobel; however, he was under great economic pressure to collect as many large licensing fees to turn a profit for his initial investors, who had the power to support or upend his career: “He had accepted their millions on the premise that he had delivered the engine of the future. [...] His future as an engineer was at stake.” (124).

Brunt uses John D. Rockefeller as a foil to Diesel’s reluctance. Unlike Diesel, whose idealistic early hopes make readers empathize with his eventual selling out, Rockefeller’s self-made background quickly gives way to his brutal business practices: insider trading schemes, price fixing, union busting, industrial espionage, and even the hiring of men to attack and allegedly murder anyone who stood in his way—underhanded tactics that he could engage in because of the power his wealth had bought. Rockefeller went to extreme lengths to maintain Standard Oil’s monopoly on the energy sector, treating competitors as foes and demanded they either “join us or perish” (57). This influence allowed Rockefeller to direct the course of industrial development, stifling innovations, such as electric cars, to force a reliance on one type of fuel.

The diesel engine’s ability to run off of a variety of fuel sources posed an obvious threat to Rockefeller’s empire—a threat journalists used to establish a motive for Diesel’s murder over a century ago. By echoing this claim, Brunt shows readers how one of the theories of Diesel’s disappearance came to be.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text