logo

59 pages 1 hour read

Abraham Cahan

The Rise of David Levinsky

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1917

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Books 5-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Book 5 Summary: “I Discover America”

David makes the voyage across the Atlantic. He performs his devotional prayers three times a day as well as performs blessings before he eats or drinks, after every meal, and before bed. David finds deep comfort in reading the Psalms over and over, especially Psalm 104. He thinks of Matilda often, even as he knows it is a sin to do so. He makes a comparison between the new born babe and the immigrant:

Imagine a new-born babe in possession of a fully developed intellect. Would it ever forget its entry into the world? Neither does the immigrant ever forget his entry into a country which is, to him, a new world in the profoundest sense of the term and in which he expects to pass the rest of his life (108).

David feels reborn into a new land, full of awe and ignorance. He has no idea where to go for shelter or food. He and another solo Orthodox traveler, Gitelson, make their way out of Sandy Hook together. They take a ferry to Castle Garden and ask a uniformed man where they should go; the man shakes them off and points them through Immigrant Station across Battery Park to State Street. They wander aimlessly, then meet a man covered in diamonds who hails them in Yiddish. The man has a smooth face and speaks words of encouragement. He asks Gitelson if he is a tailor. Gitelson goes with the man for work. The man tells David how to get to a nearby Jewish neighborhood.

David feels abandoned and wanders on experiencing a deep sense of disquiet. He makes his way to East Broadway with only 29 cents in his pocket. He arrives in the Jewish East Side to find signs in both English and Yiddish. He is referred to as a greenhorn. David buys a three-cent meal of rye bread and a wedge of cheese. He asks a woman nearby if he can use her water to perform his pre-meal prayer and ritual. She gives him a glass of milk to go with his meal. He leaves his bundle with the woman and wanders through the “Ghetto.” He runs into a man who tells him he cannot stay in the synagogue overnight, as was his plan. The man asks if he has any money. David wanders on in search of boarding. He meets a man named Mr. Even who is dignified and a leader among the men in his neighborhood. Mr. Even has heard the story of David’s mother’s death. He buys David a suit of clothes, a hat, under garments, handkerchiefs, collars, shoes, and a necktie. He sets David up for short-term boarding with a woman he knows and gets him started as a peddler.

David struggles with homesickness. He does not find the work of peddling easy or lucrative. David works on learning English as fast as possible. He finds a synagogue that is populated by people from Antomir. He spends many evenings there reading the Talmud. He moves into a different boarding house with a less kind landlady, though she is a better cook. David faces teasing for his continued adherence to Orthodoxy. He begins to break from his religious strictures. He cuts his side locks and shaves his face.

Book 6 Summary: “A Greenhorn No Longer”

David continues to peddle clothing and makes a friend in a man named Max Margolis, known as Maximum Max. Max and David become friends despite the 11-year age gap and Max’s status as a married man. Max tells David how to seduce women. Initially, David shies away from the idea, but the idea of winning a woman sinks into his brain. David begins to look at the women around him as prospects. He tests Max’s theory with his landlady. He rationalizes that there is love, like what he had for Matilda, and lust, a need to satisfy carnal hunger.

He makes more moves on his landlady; she thwarts him and tells him to seek out a younger woman. David then visits his old landlady to flirt; she is more receptive but still pushes him out. He then enters a period of unrestrained conduct with sex workers. He visits quite a few of them and learns more about politics from a particular worker called Argentine Rachael. He votes in his first election and sees money trading hands for votes.

David then enrolls in a public evening school to learn English. He studies with vigor under his teacher, Bender. David even determines to learn the gestures and sign language common to Americans. He practices whenever he can. He takes his teacher out for long rambling walks to practice his pronunciation and learn about City College. David begins to study the Bible in English to really get the language ingrained. He argues with his landlady about his kerosene usage for reading, but he settles with her by paying for more oil.

When his school ends, Bender gifts David Dombey and Son and a small dictionary. David becomes so engrossed in the novel and translating it that his cart business goes in the red and he is left penniless. He tries working as a bookkeeper, but hates it. He takes a job in New Jersey to teach Yiddish to a farmer’s wife, but soon they return to the city. Maximum Max offers David a bed and a job with him, but his leering at women who come to dance gets him fired. He continues to live on charity and credit while all the people in his life tell him to learn a trade. David moves into a music shop owned by a cantor at his synagogue. The man rails against the sins of the congregation. David continues to subsist on charity as he works for his room for the ill-tempered man.

Book 7 Summary: “My Temple”

David runs into Gitelson in the street one day. Gitelson dresses in fine clothing and seems to be doing well financially. He and David discuss their lives in America since their parting. Gitelson works as a tailor, though not for the man who recruited him. The pair go to an ice-cream parlor for sodas and continue their discussion. Gitelson boasts but maintains a demeanor of compassionate respect. He then offers to help David find a job making cloaks. David accepts, thinking of the job as a stepping stone to get to college.

A machine operator at the tailor shop Gitelson works for trains David on the manufacture of cloaks. David does not do skilled tailoring, but batch work for cheaper goods. He works from six o’clock in the morning until nine o’clock in the evening. The cloak trade is seasonal, so the men work hard for two three-month stints. They must make enough money to sustain them in the off seasons. David loathes the shop and the people in it, thinking himself superior to them all. He thinks of quitting, but the idea of failing at another job keeps him in the shop. Little by little, David begins to enjoy the work at the shop and becomes more adept at the machines. He still thinks of Matilda. He eventually comes to appreciate his coworkers and his teacher.

David still yearns to go to City College. The East Side population swells with Jewish immigrants, so the population of the college is primarily made up of young Jewish men. David becomes more passionate about making cloaks, finding ways to be more efficient by systemizing the production process. His teacher encourages him as they are both paid by volume rather than hours worked. David forms a friendship with another former Talmudist in the shop, Jake Mindels, who has a passion for Jewish theater. The two begin to attend the theater often, especially the performances of Madame Klesmer, the leading Jewish actress. Jake speaks better English but has not read as much as David. David finds him similar to his Russian friend, Naphtali. They resolve to only use English with each other.

As the cloak season comes to an end, David finds himself idle and reading more Dickens, taking up Thackeray as well. He believes Dickens is the better writer but loves Vanity Fair more. He takes up a library card and reads more and more. He continues his friendship with Jake until the next season. David manages to save $100 for the first time and becomes obsessed with having it. He opens a savings account. He prepares to get into college and leaves his job for a different cloak maker after a falling out with his teacher.

The cloak-makers’ union then calls for a strike. David joins the strike, though hesitantly. The manufacturers agree to the union’s demands, and the work begins. David dedicates himself to becoming a real American. He proposes to marry one of the women from the factory, but she knows he just wants to marry so she can support him while he is in college. Work and money lose all appeal to David. He moves to a tiny attic apartment and prepares to live on his savings while attending college. Mrs. Nodelman, his new landlady, regales him with tales of her son who opened his own factory. Meyer Nodelman, her son, and David meet. Meyer and David become friends, and Meyer asks David to teach him to read and write. Meyer pays him well for the lessons but soon gives them up as too difficult. David must return to the factory.

Book 8 Summary: “The Destruction of my Temple”

David spills his milk at work one day and the owner of the shop, Jeff Manheimer, chastises him relentlessly. David already detested Jeff, but the incident leaves David spinning in fury. David begins to think of exacting revenge. He notices another Russian immigrant, Ansel Chaikin, a talented tailor. Chaikin’s designs and skills contribute substantially to the business’s success. David realizes he could poach Chaikin and open his own shop. The idea roots in David, and he cannot stop imagining it: “I visioned myself a rich man, of course, but that was merely a detail. What really hypnotized me was the venture of the thing. It was a great, daring game of life” (223). Revenge no longer motivates David, but the idea of wealth and independence does. He convinces himself he could run a business and attend college, too.

David travels to Chaikin’s home. He does not enjoy Chaikin’s company but eventually brings up the idea of a business partnership. Chaikin seems ignorant to David’s advances, but his wife hears and engages with David. Chaikin’s domineering wife asks pointed questions. David evades what he can, playing with the couple’s small son. They talk about start-up capital, and David hedges, leading them to believe he has more money than he does. David justifies this by thinking all human interaction is acting to some extent.

David tries again to propose to his former coworker, Gussie. The two share an intimate moment while a band plays in the distance at the park. The two part, but Gussie writes him the next day, turning down his proposal. He returns to the Chaikin’s home. Mrs. Chaikin badgers him relentlessly about the money, but David continues to hedge. He begins to convince them the business will work.

David meets more often with Meyer Nodelman and quizzes him, seemingly hypothetically, about how he operates his business. Nodelman manufactures women’s clothing, but getting credit and securing premises translate to David’s goals. He gets a shop on Division Street, though Mrs. Chaikin hoped for Broadway. She continues to try to pin down David’s net worth. David opens a checking account and has Chaikin make some samples.

David travels to different department stores but has little success as he is such a small, new business. He makes no sales on his first day. Neither do the following two days. He finally makes a sale of 500 cloaks to a Western firm. He secures a loan with an American backer. The firm fills the order on time. He does not receive the money in the normal 10 days; he instead receives a notice that the company failed.

Mrs. Chaikin calls him a liar and a cheat when he tells them. She refuses to believe the business failed and thinks that David cheated them instead. David flatters her and convinces her to keep her husband working. David seeks out the man who helped him when he first arrived in America, but the man is no help. He despairs at the thought of not repaying the loan to the American Gentile. He realizes he will never go to college: “The spell of my college aspirations was broken once for all. My Temple was destroyed. Nothing was left of it but vague yearnings and something like a feeling of compunction which will assert itself, sometimes, to this day” (268). David despairs at the loss of his dream of education and the failure of his business venture.

Books 5-8 Analysis

These chapters of the novel develop the author’s central theme of Losing Jewish Identity to the American Melting Pot. David travels from Russia to the United States and slowly strips away the Orthodox pieces of himself to fit into America. His goals and identity are both set aside in the search for the American dream and assimilation into American culture. As he moves further away from Jewish Spirituality, Tradition, and Religion he simply becomes assimilated into secular materialism, losing all sense of his own identity in the process. Cahan suggests Jews should not try to assimilate so intensely, as they will simply lose their identity to capitalism; the melting pot is a myth, in other words. The novel argues that Jews should maintain their identity and practices in the US.

David establishes this dichotomy upon his arrival. He describes his entry into America as a rebirth. He does not believe that the streets of America are paved with gold, but he does not understand the true solitude of coming to a new land until he realizes that he has nowhere to sleep. Gitelson leaves him to wander the streets, but the charity of a Jewish man from Russia saves him from immediate destitution. He struggles with maintaining his Jewish identity but hates to be seen as a greenhorn. David cuts his forelocks and shaves his face to become more accepted into American society and seen as less of an outsider. The more he attempts to assimilate in to American identity, the more he loses his Jewish identity. It is not possible, the novel suggests, to assimilate into American identity without losing one’s Jewish identity; trying to assimilate too intensely will only result in a loss of all of one’s identity to secular capitalism.

David holds on to his dream of education even as he seeks out a meager living as a peddler. The work does not suit him, but he maintains his love for God, attending the synagogue and reading the Bible in English. It is not until the entry of Maximum Max Margolis that David begins to stray from the tenets of Orthodox Judaism in practice. David gives in to lust and has liaisons with sex workers and attempts to seduce married women. David clutches to the desires he had in Russia, the dream of Matilda and College captivating him as he reads Dickenson and sleeps with multiple women. He holds the contradiction of the two worlds within him. The boy who left Russia holds the romantic illusion of reuniting with Matilda as an educated man, that she will take him seriously and love him. He has devoted the first two decades of his life to the pursuit of knowledge and truth. He holds on to the dream more tightly than he held the first $100 he earned. The novel continues to depict Jewish Spirituality, Tradition, and Religion as David still, in the early stages of American life, practices his religion and attempts to remain connected to his Jewish traditions. This attempt slowly fades, however, as he becomes more assimilated into American life. David loses all sense of Jewish spirituality and tradition and thus loses his connection to his home and his sense of self.

American capitalism takes over his heart and his head as he sees the opportunity to strike out on his own in business. David follows the allure of a stable marriage with Gussie, but she turns him down, closing the door on his Talmudic student’s dream of being supported while he studies. He turns instead to business. He pulls Chaikin into his plot to overthrow the Menheimers. David tells himself that he can be both a scholar and businessman. He convinces the Chaikins to follow the American dream as well. David does not worry about the lies, half-truths, and insinuations he must use to convince them to sign on. He views these means as righteous as it is for their own good.

The failure of the Western company drives David into deep despair. He humbles himself to reach out to Mr. Even but is turned away. He realizes that he must let go of the dream of college, the embodiment of the dream that pushed him out of Russia. Cahan titles Book 8, “The Destruction of My Temple,” causing the reader to see the loss of David’s academic aspirations as a break with his religious Orthodoxy. David sacrifices his desire for education for the chance at wealth. For David, this change is more dramatic and indicative of his loss of faith than any other outward sign, such as shaving his face, could be. David gives up his faith, his dreams, his religious practices, his native language, and pieces of his race to assimilate into American culture and make it as a businessman. The novel explores Exploitative Socioeconomic Mobility and Capitalism here as the American dream is portrayed as a myth that only makes David lose his faith and culture. He begins to pursue wealth and realizes that it is not possible to achieve the dream with individual hard work itself; he begins to exploit others to rise above them and in the process destroys all sense of community he has with others and his Jewish culture. Climbing the social ladder is only a source of destruction in these chapters.

Cahan makes it clear that David’s choices in women, trade, and business are choices. David recognizes that he could go to college, that he could struggle, that he could find a good Jewish wife, but he chooses the adventure of starting a business and the romanticism of unattainable love. David is an adventurer by nature. He takes big risks. The danger compels him. Yet, he stays safe in his personal life, choosing women that cannot hurt him. Money represents a reasonable risk for David, as he has lived most of his life without it. He does not risk attachment though, as the loss of one person he truly loved, his mother, left a hole in him that he can neither face nor repair.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text