logo

59 pages 1 hour read

Mariame Kaba

We Do This 'Til We Free Us: Abolitionist Organizing and Transforming Justice

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 7Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 7: “Show Up and Don’t Travel Alone: We Need Each Other”

Part 7, Chapter 1 Summary: “‘Community Matters. Collectivity Matters’: Interview by Damon Williams and Daniel Kisslinger, Airgo, July 220”

At an extremely busy time for activism (only two months after the murder of George Floyd), Kaba finds herself both saying no to some opportunities and accepting new challenges. There is no predicting what will happen or what her proper place within events might be: “[M]y only conviction is that we ought to be organizing steadily always. All of the time” (164-65). There is no way to predict when decades worth of activism will finally hit the mainstream, but they must be ready when it does. Kaba believes that there will be failures, and just as failure is normalized in the tech or banking space, it should be normalized in the activism space as well. Everyone expects Kaba and her fellow activists to have everything planned out, but “the problem with policing, prisons, and surveillance is that it’s a one-size-fits-all model” and they are not looking to replicate the same logic (166). What matters is building a space where creative alternatives can flourish. Activist groups are not trying to create models, so much as experiment, learn, and collaborate with others. Many groups are based around specific communities and circumstances, and so what they do may not be applicable to others.

Creativity—not just in terms of developing alternatives, but practicing actual art—is an important part of activism because “the cops are in our heads and our hearts” and so people must be free to imagine a world where they are not reliant on the police in every facet of their lives (169). Even beyond the police, it is important to get beyond the logic that legitimizes the police, but also informs other institutions such as child welfare and mental health. Kaba is very encouraged by the work she sees around her, especially the work of young people, and has been quite reluctant to make herself a public figure for fear of interfering with their distinct ways of doing things: “This is less about me and more about a movement that I’ve been part of for a long time” (174). The community matters much more than the individual, and she hopes to see young people continue to model that principle.

Part 7, Chapter 2 Summary: “Everything Worthwhile Is Done with Other People: Interview by Eve L. Ewing, Adi Magazine, Fall 2019”

Kaba comes from a family of activists, as her father was part of the struggle to liberate Guinea from French colonialism, until he had a falling out with its first president as the president asserted dictatorial control. From her father she learned “the importance of collectivity. WE can’t do anything alone that’s worth it” (177), and while her mother was not political, she demonstrated extraordinary kindness to members of their community and taught Kaba not to impose borders between herself and other people.

Kaba is interested in relationships, not narratives, and because so much of learning comes through narratives, people need to get out and actually engage with others if they want to be a part of the movement. Individuals can be activists, focusing on specific issues and engaging as they see fit, while organizing is an intensely social activity with a broader strategic vision. Kaba has struggled with the question of whether and how to place herself publicly in her activism, whether a public presence would distract from the movement or, as a friend once told her, would be “erasing herself from history” (182). She thinks of the people who have inspired her, like James Baldwin, Ida Wells-Barnett, and Angela Davis, and while she seems reluctant to be considered someone else’s hero, she does appreciate when her writing and action has a positive impact on others.

Kaba also frankly acknowledges how war can be an engine of social progress, just as the Civil War helped destroy slavery and World War II laid the groundwork for the civil rights movement. Despite this sobering thought, Kaba considers herself an optimistic person, especially because she realizes that success or failure does not rest on her shoulders alone.

Part 7, Chapter 3 Summary: “Resisting Police Violence Against Black Women and Women of Color: Remarks at ‘Invisible No More: Resisting Police Violence Against Black Women and Women of Color in Troubled Times,’ Barnard College, New York, November 2017”

Kaba has been involved in activism since she was a teenager, beginning with protests against the killing of an elderly Black woman at the hands of the NYPD, with the officer facing no consequences. At first Kaba thought of herself as a Black activist, but developed a sense of herself as a Black woman later in life, inspired in large part by the Philadelphia police’s terror bombing of the MOVE compound in 1985.

People tend to count the casualties of attacks, but Kaba thinks more in terms of accumulation, of atrocity after atrocity that reveals a systemic problem. Once people come to understand “policing as a system that’s actually about harassment, violence, and surveillance […] you’re going to understand from the beginning that we’re talking about is the horizon of abolition. It’s the only way” (188).

Part 7, Chapter 4 Summary: “Join the Abolitionist Movement: Interview with Rebel Steps”

Now that calls to defund the police have entered the mainstream, there is a danger of bad-faith actors trying to defang the movement, but Kaba also wants to be patient with the fact that there are various groups involved with their own priorities. As long as they focus on the abolition of “premature death and organized abandonment” there is room for a big tent (190). Abolitionists can work with non-abolitionists to advance meaningful reforms, so long as it does not foreclose the abolitionist vision. All those who are “willing to be transformed in the service of the work” will find themselves welcome (191).

Part 7, Chapter 5 Summary: “‘I Must Become a Menace to My Enemies’: The Living Legacy of June Jordan: Remarks at ‘The Difficult Miracle: The Living Legacy of June Jordan,’ Cambridge, Massachusetts, February 2018”

Kaba is honored to speak at an event commemorating June Jordan, who was a major influence on her as a young activist. She thinks of a man she knew named Michael who had been shot, that even though he survived the wound, his life remains precarious. He once took pride in making himself uncomfortable, and so he reminded Kaba of Jordan’s poem with its line: “I must become a menace to my enemies” (194). Michael is emblematic of the failures of the American state to provide for its Black youth, only for the state to then turn the troubles Black youth face into evidence of personal and racial pathology. Michael was not part of a movement, “because his struggle is to live day to day” (196). He is courageous in this respect, as are the many young Black people who have stood down police in their fight for dignity and justice. The example of June Jordan, who died in 2002, is a needed reminder that love is at the center of struggle, that “hope is a discipline” (196).

Part 7 Analysis

This section is by far the most personal, with Kaba delving into her own life and sense of herself as an activist and an organizer. The entire book is in many respects her emergence as a national, public figure. As she describes, for many years she shunned anything even hinting of the spotlight: “I grew up with mentors telling me that the organizer is never up front” (182). Part of this is surely modesty, but it is also a reflection of her anti-individualistic perspective: The center of her entire project is empowering communities, encouraging people to seek solidarity outside of themselves, and so a movement revolved around a charismatic personality could do injury to that project. At the same time, she traces her own lineage through her activist parents to the many heroes who inspired her with their example. While characteristically modest about her own contributions, Kaba comes to think: “[H]ow are people going to be able to trace the lineage of ideas if I’m writing a whole bunch of things that no one knows I wrote, right? [...] [A]t least put your name on your shit” (182).

Reflecting on her career, Kaba offers deep insights into the nature of Activism and Community Organizing. She distinguishes the theme’s two concepts, describing activism as a primarily individual activity that one takes up to address a specific issue; by contrast, Kaba states:

[Organizing] is thinking through a vision, a strategy, and then figuring out who your targets are. It requires being focused on power, and figuring out how to build power to push your issues, in order to get the target to actually move in the way that you want to (180).

While this description makes organizing sound very goal-oriented, at the same time Kaba is insistent that organizing must not subscribe to the same rules of success as mainstream institutions. She scoffs at those who say, “‘Evaluate yourself. Show us the best practice. What is your effectiveness?’ The language of neoliberal efficiency models” (168). The ultimate value in organizing lies in the name: bringing people together for a common purpose, for experimenting with different forms of action and communal bonding.

Kaba thus underscores the idea that success can take many forms in abolitionist work. Organizers may have tremendous difficulty in changing the behavior of the state, but simply by making themselves public, they reveal the limits of state power, that the state cannot make them go away, submit quietly, or subscribe to their rules without a fight. After decades of working behind the scenes, Kaba herself is now sufficiently confident in the viability of her position that she is now a public figure actively looking to shape the public conversation around policing and prisons. Whatever specific goals she may accomplish or help to inspire, the book itself (especially given its success) is proof that change is a real possibility, even if its impact is not evident at the time that people are making it.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text