65 pages • 2 hours read
Daniel Walker HoweA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Howe explores the Whig Party’s role and influence in American politics, particularly focusing on the period surrounding William Henry Harrison’s presidency and John Tyler’s subsequent presidency. He covers a broad range of themes, including political ideology, economic policies, internal conflicts, and the party’s contributions to American society and governance.
The chapter begins with the scene of William Henry Harrison’s inauguration in 1841, underlining the historical significance of his lengthy speech, which criticized Democratic policies and emphasized the principles of the Whig Party. Harrison’s promises of executive restraint and a one-term presidency reflect the Whig’s ideological commitment to a balanced federal government and their critique of what they perceived as the Democratic Party’s overreach under Andrew Jackson.
The sudden death of Harrison a month into his presidency and the ascension of John Tyler, a man whose political beliefs often diverged from core Whig principles, marks a pivotal moment in the chapter. Tyler’s presidency is portrayed as a period of internal strife within the Whig Party, highlighting his controversial veto of the bill to establish a third bank of the United States and his alienation from the Whig leadership. This event is critical in illustrating the ideological fractures within the party and Tyler’s complex legacy as a president caught between his personal beliefs and the expectations of his party.
Howe gives attention to the Whig Party’s agenda and its attempts to navigate and shape the political and economic landscape of the United States. The chapter discusses the party’s support for infrastructure development, the American system of economic protectionism, and its advocacy for social reforms. It delves into the legislative battles, political maneuvers, and ideological underpinnings of Whig policies, which included a strong, proactive role for the federal government in fostering economic development and social stability. This contrasted the Democratic emphasis on laissez-faire economics and a more limited federal government.
The Harrisburg Convention of 1839 is highlighted as a crucial event in Whig political strategy, leading to Harrison’s nomination over Henry Clay and setting the stage for the 1840 presidential election. This election, characterized by its populist campaigning and the use of symbols like the log cabin and hard cider, is depicted as a moment of triumph for the Whigs, despite the challenges that would follow in Harrison’s brief presidency and Tyler’s contentious relationship with the party.
Internal conflicts within the Whig Party, particularly between Tyler and Whig congressional leaders, are explored in depth, showcasing the difficulties in maintaining party cohesion and advancing a unified agenda. The chapter examines the consequences of these conflicts, including the impact on the party’s legislative goals and the broader implications for American politics.
The American Renaissance was a transformative moment in the nation’s cultural history catalyzed by William Ellery Channing’s sermon in 1819. Channing’s address in Baltimore not only merged Protestant Christianity with Enlightenment ideals, positing science and the Bible as compatible, but also laid the groundwork for a broader, progressive interpretation of the Bible and, by extension, the Constitution. This synthesis heralded a new dawn of intellectual and cultural expansion that transcended traditional Calvinist dogma, advocating for human moral improvement and the broadening of intellectual horizons.
Channing’s rejection of the Trinity and predestination, and his advocacy for Unitarian Christianity, sparked widespread debate within religious and intellectual circles, making his sermon as a manifesto for a liberal religious outlook. This sermon circulated extensively, becoming a pivotal text in American pamphlet literature and encapsulating a shift towards a more inclusive and humane theological discourse.
The chapter further explores the ripple effects of this intellectual shift, observing its impact on social reforms, education, and the abolition of slavery and imperialism. Channing’s advocacy for the education of the laboring classes and opposition to slavery positioned him as a seminal figure in the nexus of religion, reform, and intellectualism. His views influenced contemporaries and later figures, contributing to the advancement of public education, women’s rights, and a more equitable society.
Channing’s Christian humanism is a precursor to the Transcendentalist movement, which further expanded the American intellectual and cultural landscape. Transcendentalism, with its emphasis on the individual’s direct experience of the divine and the inherent goodness of people, found resonance in the works of Emerson, Thoreau, and Fuller, among others, marking a period of vibrant literary and philosophical activity known as the American Renaissance.
Howe details the historical journey leading to the annexation of Texas, highlighting the significant roles played by various individuals, technological advances, and political maneuvers. The chapter begins with the early 19th-century backdrop, setting the stage with Erasmo Seguín and Stephen Austin’s entrance into Texas, then a part of New Spain, emphasizing the initial efforts to populate Texas with settlers from the United States for economic and strategic purposes. It narrates the transition of Texas from Spanish control to becoming a part of Mexico, and the eventual settlement of Anglo Americans, which laid the groundwork for the Texan independence movement.
The narrative covers the political and social dynamics between the Anglo settlers and Mexican authorities, including issues over slavery, cultural and religious differences, and the struggle for autonomy within the Mexican federation. In addition to being a battle for independence, the Texan Revolution was driven by a mix of economic, political, and social factors. Key players in the conflict included Mexican President Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna (1794-1876) and Texas Secretary of State Stephen Austin (1793-1836). The Texan Revolution’s aftermath led to the US’s efforts to acquire Texas, sparking political debates over its annexation.
The chapter provides a detailed account of the technological innovation of the telegraph by Samuel Morse. This technological breakthrough significantly enhanced the efficiency of commercial transactions, enabling real-time updates on market prices and facilitating quicker business decisions, thus driving economic growth. For national expansion, the telegraph played a critical role by improving coordination across vast territories, supporting the logistics of railroads, and bolstering military communication. Its ability to instantly connect distant parts of the country also fostered a sense of national unity and identity, laying the groundwork for the modern telecommunications infrastructure that would continue to shape societal transformations.
The narrative concludes with the strategic political maneuvers by John Tyler and others to secure Texas’s annexation to the US, against a backdrop of domestic and international opposition, showcasing the complex interplay of politics, technology, and imperial ambition in the shaping of American history during this period. The annexation of Texas is presented as a pivotal moment, influenced by a diverse array of factors including the telegraph’s development, which marked a significant expansion of the United States and set the stage for further territorial and technological advancements.
The presidency of James Knox Polk shaped the trajectory of the United States during the mid-19th century. Polk’s presidency, beginning with his inauguration on March 4, 1845, set the stage for a significant expansion of American territory. Polk pursued the annexation of Texas, sought the acquisition of California and New Mexico, and was determined to settle the Oregon Territory dispute with Britain. His ambition was not only to expand the territory of the United States but also to extend its influence and open new avenues for commerce and trade, particularly towards Asia through the Pacific.
Polk’s determination to acquire Texas and resolve the Oregon Territory dispute brought him into direct conflict with Mexico and Great Britain. Mexico viewed the annexation of Texas as an act of aggression, leading to strained relations and setting the stage for the Mexican-American War. Polk positioned troops along the disputed Texas-Mexico border, which eventually incited the conflict that Polk sought, enabling the United States to significantly expand its territory as a result.
The chapter also delves into the internal politics of Polk’s administration, highlighting his political acumen in balancing the interests of different factions within his party and the nation. Polk’s policies, particularly the annexation of Texas and the pursuit of territory in the Southwest, were intertwined with the issue of slavery’s expansion into new territories, exacerbating regional tensions within the United States.
Moreover, Polk’s vision of Manifest Destiny and his administration’s actions significantly impacted the Indigenous populations and the Mexican residents of the annexed territories. The acquisition of these lands led to their displacement and the imposition of American laws, altering the demographic and cultural landscapes of the newly acquired territories.
The chapter also reflects on the consequences of Polk’s expansionist policies, both immediate and long-term. While they resulted in significant territorial gains, such as the inclusion of Texas, parts of the Oregon Territory, and the vast territories acquired through the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo following the Mexican-American War, these actions also sowed the seeds for future conflicts, particularly the Civil War. The question of whether newly acquired territories would permit slavery exacerbated sectional divisions, highlighting the complex interplay between expansionism, slavery, and other political dynamics of the era.
Chapters 17 and 18 focus on Polk’s presidency, emphasizing his use of Manifest Destiny to support the US’s expansion into new territories. The acquisition of Texas and other Mexican territories were the most significant in reshaping the nation’s landscape and identity. The political and military maneuvering needed for this expansion underscore the era’s challenges, including diplomatic tensions and the moral implications of displacing Indigenous and Mexican populations. This continues the theme of The Political and Social Challenges of Territorial Expansion. The chapters illustrate, once again, how expansion was driven by a belief in America’s destined role on the continent yet fraught with conflicts that tested the nation’s democratic principles and its stance on sovereignty and international law.
This section highlights the importance of The Mexican-American War and its implications for Indigenous lands within the acquired territories. The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, which concluded the conflict, resulted in Mexico ceding vast swaths of land to the United States, including present-day California, Arizona, New Mexico, and parts of Colorado, Nevada, and Utah. This transfer of territory further encroached upon Indigenous lands, exacerbating displacement and dispossession. Indigenous peoples in these regions faced increased pressure from settlers and the US government, leading to forced removals, broken treaties, and ongoing conflicts over land and resources, perpetuating a cycle of injustice and marginalization.
While Chapter 15 discusses the Whig Party’s ideological stance, focusing on economic and infrastructural development, Chapter 16 delves into the American Renaissance, highlighting The Rise of Religious and Social Movements. The emphasis on Unitarian Christianity’s compatibility with rational thought reflect the era’s engagement with moral and ethical questions, including those surrounding slavery. These chapters illustrate how religious and intellectual movements contributed to a vibrant public discourse, fostering a climate of reform and questioning that permeated various aspects of American life.
The Evolving Debate and Conflict over Slavery continue as it expanded into new territories. territorial expansion is a recurring theme, particularly as it pertains to the annexation of Texas and the Mexican Cession. The chapters reveal how debates over slavery influenced the strategies of political parties and further divided the nation’s moral and ideological landscape. The Whig Party’s internal divisions, the Democratic Party’s stance under Polk, and the broader societal debates captured in these chapters reflect the deepening national crisis over slavery.
Slavery was also a technological issue. The cotton gin’s invention, which occurred during the era covered in What Hath God Wrought, highlights the complex relationship between technological advancement, economic growth, and the human rights issues at the heart of the slavery debate. While this technology significantly boosted the cotton industry’s efficiency and profitability, leading to economic prosperity, it also deepened the South’s reliance on slave labor by increasing the demand for cotton cultivation. As a result, the South became stauncher in its support of slavery as a moral good, driving the nation closer to the conflicts that would ultimately lead to the Civil War. The cotton gin’s invention is emblematic of the broader theme of the evolving debate over slavery, reflecting the intertwined nature of technology, economy, and societal values in shaping the nation’s history and the contentious path towards addressing the contradictions inherent in American democracy.