84 pages • 2 hours read
Diana GabaldonA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In Los Angeles, Brianna receives a letter from Roger. Written in 1739, the letter alerts Brianna to Roger’s true position in time. She updates her Practical Guide for Time Travelers, concluding that traveling with a faceted gem allows better control and that the body’s electromagnetism results in an electric attraction between loved ones, alluding to Walt Whitman’s poem I Sing the Body Electric (1855).
Roger and Buck find Mr. Cumberpatch, learning that the dog tags came from near Hadrian’s Wall. They plan to walk along the wall until they hear word of Roger’s father, and Roger obtains a large garnet from Mrs. Cumberpatch while purchasing supplies. That night, Roger reveals that Buck’s father and mother were Dougal MacKenzie and Geillis Abernathy.
Unsure if she should travel through the American stones to Claire and Jamie or the Scottish stones to Roger, Brianna travels to Boston to seek Joe Abernathy’s advice. While there, Jem reveals that even now he can hear and locate both Mandy and Roger. The next morning, Brianna commits fully to traveling to the past.
On the fourth day of traveling along Hadrian’s Wall, Roger and Buck see a man wearing Jerry MacKenzie’s flight jacket. The man refuses to talk to them, calling his dog on them instead. Instead of searching for Jerry, they decide to find the standing stones he would have traveled through and ask about strangely dressed men there.
Joe and Brianna discover Mandy and Jem can sense each other up to four miles. Deciding to travel through Craigh na Dun, Brianna refuses Joe and Gail Abernathy’s offer to accompany her to Scotland. She will avoid Inverness and Robbie Cameron until just before they go through the stones.
Roger and Buck recruit a young boy named Ridley to guide them to the standing stones. Ridley also guides them to a man who found a RAF flight harness. Noticing Ridley’s reaction to the harness, they discover that a local clan has beaten and robbed a stranger. Farmer Quarton is holding the stranger while deciding between killing him or cutting off his hand for stealing a pie.
Roger and Buck rescue Jerry MacKenzie from a locked cow byre (a cowshed) that night. Buck tells Jerry they come from a long way from now. Chased by the farmer and his dogs as they leave, they escape and take Jerry back to the standing stones. Roger gives his father the garnet, and warns Jerry to only think about his wife, not his son. Just before Jerry steps into the stones, Roger hugs him, telling him he loves him.
As Jerry goes through the stones, Roger and Buck lose consciousness. When they wake, they decide to travel to Cranesmuir so Buck can meet Geillis. Roger tells Buck a little about his mother but withholds information about Geillis’ sordid history.
In A Practical Guide to Time Travelers, Brianna writes that they will take the train to Inverness the next day, and Fiona will take them to Craigh na Dun. Brianna has warned Lional Menzies to keep an eye on Robbie.
Roger and Buck meet Geillis in her home but are surprised to find Dr. McEwan there as well; Roger can tell McEwan and Geillis recently had sex. Buck asks Geillis to look at Roger’s throat, then insinuates he has more delicate ailments for her to look at. Geillis takes Buck up to her attic, leaving Roger and McEwan behind.
Roger explains that Buck is Geillis’ son, and that she is a time traveler like themselves. McEwan admits that he and Geillis conceived a child, and she aborted the fetus with his approval. Roger leaves in disgust, walking around the square to cool off. Returning to the house, he comforts McEwan and allows him to heal his throat again. He advises McEwan to leave Geillis, but McEwan tells Roger that though he has tried, he cannot.
When Buck and Roger retire to an inn, Buck confesses that he did not have sex with his mother, though she offered herself to him. Roger will not confirm Buck’s belief that his mother is a “whore,” but Buck tells him that he will never make a good minister if he cannot tell the truth (822).
Leaving Crainsmuir, Buck apologizes to Roger for causing the hanging that robbed Roger of his voice. He offers to travel back in time to update Brianna, leaving Roger free to search for Jem. Roger is going to travel to Lallybroch and urges Buck to see Dougal MacKenzie before taking the trip through the stones.
Brianna, Jem, and Mandy are approaching Craigh na Dun when Lionel Menzies appears, warning her that Robbie and his friends are in pursuit. Brianna gives Jem and Mandy their gems, and Mandy, feeling her father’s presence, disappears into a stone. Jem retrieves her, reappearing immediately, but their gems have been destroyed. As Robbie’s gang charges up the hillside, Lionel breaks apart his Masonic ring on a stone, giving one diamond each to Jem and Mandy. Brianna grabs her children’s hands and steps through the stones.
In 1739, Brianna and the children walk to Lallybroch, taking refuge in the broch. Through the window, Jem sees a man climbing the hill and, believing it’s Roger, Brianna runs to meet him. However, it’s Brian Fraser, visiting the graves of his wife and his son. Brian mistakes Brianna for the ghost of Ellen and seeing Jem follow Brianna, thinks Jem is the ghost of his son. He passes out from shock. Jem excitedly tells Brianna that Mandy can hear Roger.
Roger wrestles with his conscience while riding to Lallybroch. He wants to alert Brianna to where he is, but fears Buck will have another heart attack traveling through the stones. Engrossed in his thoughts, he looks up and sees Jem in the road. They joyfully reunite and Jem tells his father that Brianna is beyond the hill, having hurt her ankle trying to catch Mandy. As Roger searches the hill for his daughter, Buck appears down the road with Mandy on his horse.
Roger, Brianna, Jem, and Mandy, spend the night in Dr. McEwan’s house. McEwan is staying with a friend, while Buck says he will stay in an inn. After the children fall asleep, Brianna tells Roger about Robbie Cameron, and Roger explains about Geillis and Buck, telling her that they cannot stay in Scotland because they know too much of what will happen to the people here.
Before falling asleep, Roger checks on the children and sees a light in Geillis Duncan’s attic. Below, a man watches. Roger turns away, but in his mind sees a vision of Buck in Geillis’ arms, slowly disappearing while Geillis watches in horror and a blue glow rises to her womb.
The section title, The Ties that Bind, references not only familial ties, but also the ties that love creates between lovers. These ties interfere with duty but are also an obligation in themselves. Roger’s obligation towards his family frequently conflicts with his duty as a minister. When he discovers his father’s dog tags, he must decide between searching for Jem, whom he feels is not in this time, or helping his father, who disappeared with his plane during WW2. His yearning to help his father is further complicated by the paradox of time travel. His father never makes it back to his own time in Roger’s timeline, so helping him in 1739 may not help. Roger decides to help Jerry solely to see his father at least once in his life, because both Jem and Jerry’s fates cannot change. When he gives Jerry the garnet, however, he is also abandoning Brianna, as the jewel was his ticket back to his own timeline. The ties towards his father take precedence here, since Roger reasons he can always find another gem. Coming to terms with his need to see his father also motivates Roger to disclose Buck’s parentage, recognizing that regardless of what that knowledge might do to the past, Buck still deserves to meet his parents while he has the chance.
Roger’s struggle to behave as a minister towards people he knows will commit evil acts illuminates the selflessness of his character; he genuinely wants to be forgiving and non-judgmental, but he still has difficulty praying for characters such as Jack Randall, Geillis, or even Dr. McEwan. When he learns that McEwan abandoned his family and impregnated Geillis, Roger attempts to make a sound meant to be “regretful and compassionate, but whether his feelings or his larynx got the better of him, it emerged as a rather stern ‘Hrmph!’” (817). Further learning that McEwan gave tacit approval to the subsequent abortion, Roger tells McEwan that if he were to judge him, he would damn him to hell.
Roger fights against his instincts to judge others, especially when it pertains to family and children. He leaves McEwan to control his outrage and returns to minister to McEwan. His realization that “You didn’t walk away from people who were drowning, even if they’d jumped into a quagmire on purpose,” illustrates his triumph over his own feelings and his renewed sense of duty towards those who he sees as his flock (817). He alleviates McEwan’s despair by telling him he is needed and proves it by allowing McEwan to further heal his throat. Roger reverts to being judgmental when he tells McEwan that it’s a good thing that there aren’t more women like Geillis, but quickly checks himself, rationalizing that if he can pray for Jack Randall, then he can do no less for his own great-grandmother “homicidal maniac or not” (820). However, the ties that bind come into play when Roger attempts to save McEwan from Geillis. Urging the doctor to leave, Roger hints that Geillis might kill him. But the doctor refuses to leave, even to save his own life. He is unable to resist the ties that join him to the witch.
Family ties come into play again when Roger refuses to confirm Buck’s assertion that Geillis is a sex worker. His concern for his ancestor’s feelings rouses Buck, who reprimands Roger, telling him “Ye’ll never make a decent minister [...] if ye can’t be honest” (822). Buck’s concern for Roger reveals the ties that he feels towards Roger and the sacrifices he is willing to make for Brianna, Jem, and Mandy. His offer to go travel through time to warn Brianna is especially dangerous because he suffered a heart attack when he last time-traveled, and the chances of his traveling back to his own time are virtually nil for the same reason. Buck believes, however, that he has nothing but his descendants to live for; he has severed his ties to his own wife and child so she can be with another man. This is in stark contrast to McEwan’s possessive love for Geillis; the doctor cannot leave her because he can’t bear the thought of her with anyone else.
Buck, then, emerges as a heroic figure, telling Roger that he is willing to sacrifice his life to warn Brianna because “Ye’re all mine, aren’t ye? [...] My blood. My…sons” (826). This presents a quandary for Roger because as a minister, his duty is to tell Buck to return to his wife. He also admits that he selfishly doesn’t want Buck to die, which means that Buck will remain in this time and susceptible to Geillis’ charms. Roger is relieved of his moral dilemma when Buck appears on the road to Lallybroch with Mandy in his arms. Buck’s demonstrates his ties to Roger’s family when he stays at Roger’s insistence, and in response to finding Mandy and Jem, makes “an incoherent noise [...] looking up through his tears [...] making an inadequate attempt at hiding his own emotions” (847).
Gabaldon references the time travel paradox repeatedly in this section; Brianna is afraid to enter Lallybroch because Jamie might be there and meeting him now may jettison their first meeting in America. Roger cannot warn the Frasers about Captain Randall, because without the chain of events that lead to Jamie’s going to prison, his own family may never exist. Brianna is torn upon seeing Brian Fraser at the broch, wanting to warn him of his impending death but unable to for the same reason as Roger. Her and Roger’s knowledge of the fates of the people they meet is dangerous; anything they say or do could affect their own existence. Buck, however, does not fully grasp the significance of the time paradox, and Roger envisions a scenario where Buck impregnates Geillis and negates his own conception, causing him to be erased from existence.
By Diana Gabaldon
Chicanx Literature
View Collection
Fate
View Collection
Forgiveness
View Collection
Hispanic & Latinx American Literature
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection
TV Shows Based on Books
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection